Skip to main content
State of Vermont Judiciary
Court Information
Judicial Community
Legal Information
Contact Us
Public Education
Representing Yourself
You are here ► State of Vermont Judiciary > Legal Community 
Go Search


Legal Community

Vermont Supreme Court Oral Arguments

Supreme Court Building

After reviewing the briefs, the Court determines whether the case will be heard by the full Court or a three-justice panel. If requested by a party, the Court grants oral argument, although it may direct that a case will be considered on the briefs without oral argument.

Cases assigned to a three-justice panel generally involve fewer issues and/or issues in which the applicable law is settled. The decision of a three-justice panel must be unanimous and a short written decision is issued in each case, usually within 48 hours of argument. Oral argument in these cases is limited to five minutes per side. Parties may appear in person or by video conference. A party planning to appear by video must notify the Court no later than three business days before the scheduled argument date. See V.R.A.P. 33.1(b).

Oral argument in cases heard by the full Court is generally for thirty minutes, fifteen minutes per side. These cases are decided after oral argument by written opinion.

The Court’s schedule is generally available a month in advance of argument on the Court’s website Supreme Court Calendar . Audio recordings of past oral arguments are also available below.

To listen to an argument click on the month the case was heard.  Then once you find the case click on the docket number to hear the case.  If you are looking for cases that are not listed please contact the Vermont Supreme Court Clerk to gain access to the audio argument.  You will need Windows Media Player, this is a free download, click the icon below to download,  if you do not have Windows Media Player.  This works best with Internet Explorer.  
TitleHearing DateCase Name
expand Year of Argument: 2015
2014-2231/8/2015Michael Rinaldo v. Green Mountain Self Storage and Jim O'Dell
2014-3421/8/2015In re J.D., Juvenile
2014-1411/21/2015State v. Stephen L. Eldert
2014-2391/21/2015The Stratton Corp. a/k/a Stratton Mountain Corp. and Intrawest Stratton Dev. Corp. v. Engleberth Const. Inc. v. Morgan's Roofing and Const., et al.
2014-2301/21/2015Bradford's Trucking, Inc. v. Dept. of Labor
2014-0471/21/2015State v. Jeremy Lucas
2014-3653/5/2015Town of Colchester v. Robert K. Andres
2014-3312/5/2015State v. James v. King
2014-204, 2014-2292/5/2015State v. Robert J. Mongeon
2014-3122/18/2015AIG Insurance Management Service, Inc. v. Vermont Department of Taxes
2014-3002/18/2015State v. David Wisowaty
2014-3352/18/2015State v. Zahariah Theodorou
2014-3343/5/2015Ricky Curtis, Jr. v. Andrew Pallito, Commissioner of Dept. of Corrections, Robert Berthiaume and Scott Morley
2014-3053/5/2015Colby M. Cheever v. Crystal Merrick
2014-3903/17/2015Kathleen Vanderbloom v. State, Agency of Transportation
2014-2753/17/2015Janet McKinstry and Mark McKinstry v. Fecteau Residential Homes, Inc. d/b/a Fecteau Homes
2014-2063/17/2015In re T.S.S.
2014-3523/16/2015In re Champlain Parkway Act 250 Permit
2014-0093/16/2015State v. Peter A. Goewey
2014-3303/16/2015William Deveneau v. Susan Weilt and Brian Toomey
2014-3164/9/2015Kristen E. Brosnahan v. William J. Brosnahan
2014-4334/9/2015David D. Smalley v. Stowe Mountain Club, Inc.
2014-2354/9/2015Kayla L. Eaton v. Leroy E. Prior, Prior Polygraph, Matthew Belmay and VT State Police
2014-4494/9/2015In re M.S., Juvenile
2014-4104/22/2015State v. Paul Aiken
2014-2464/22/2015In re Derrick Brown
2014-2704/23/2015Debra L. McGee v. Justin Gonyo
2014-2964/23/2015In re Estate of Dezotelle
2014-3694/23/2015In re Willowell Conditional Use Certificate of Occupancy
2014-4545/13/2015State v. Hillary Lumbra
2014-1675/13/2015State v. Scott Manfredi`
2014-4315/13/2015Nina Darling v. Theodore Crow
2014-3755/13/2015Charles Chandler v. State
2014-3965/26/2015Carole Kuligoski, Individually and on behalf of Michael Kuligoski, Mark Kuligoski and James Kuligoski v. Brattleboro Retreat and Northeast Kingdom Human Services
2014-2695/26/2015State v. Salahdin Trowell
2014-1965/27/2015State v. Kent Richland, Jr.
2014-2075/27/2015State v. Eric K. Manning
2014-4415/27/2015Cenlar FSB v. Joseph L. Malenfant, Laurie Malenfant and New England Federal Credit Union
2015-0225/27/2015In re J.M., Juvenile
2014-332, 2014-3576/11/2015State v. Matthew Fay
2015-0276/11/2015In re Zaremba Group Dollar General Conditional Use Permit
2015-0296/11/2015In re D.S., Juvenile
2015-0646/11/2015Brian Farr-Maccione v. Department of Labor (Vermont Teddy Bear Co. Inc., Appellee)
2014-4656/22/2015John T. Adams II v. Town of Sudbury
2015-0676/22/2015In re Petition of VTEL Wireless Inc. for Certificiate of Public Good
2014-3626/23/2015State v. Thomas Bryan
expand Year of Argument: 2014
2012-2541/8/2014State v. Yetha I. Lumumba
2013-2631/8/2014Michael Parker and Judith Parker v. David Potter and Susan Potter
2013-2911/9/2014Edward Wesolow v. Town of Lowell
2013-3161/9/2014In re Grievance of VSEA (Tropical Storm Irene Emergency Closing)
2013-3011/22/2014In re UVM Certificate of Appropriateness
2013-2031/22/2014In re Bradford Trucking, Inc.
2013-3881/22/2014In re B.R., Juvenile
2013-3542/19/2014Vermont Federal Credit Union v. Drew Richter and Russell Richter
2013-1893/12/2014James A. Brault & Elise D. Brault v. Jeanne E. Welch
2013-3733/12/2014Town of Ira v. Vermont League of Cities and Towns
2013-3863/17/2014Ralph Nelson v. Town of St. Johnsbury Selectboard, et al.
2013-366, 2013-3673/17/2014In re Wastewater System & Potable Water Supply Permit WW-1-1949 / In re Petition to Revoke Wastewater & Potable Supply Permit WW-1-1949
2013-2503/17/2014Michaela & David Martin as Next Best Friends to Gracie Martin v. Cooperative Ins. Co. of VT, Lakeside Campground, John S. Christman & Joanna L. Christman
2013-4293/27/2014State v. Kevin Terrance Shea a/k/a Eejipp Ala
2013-2173/27/2014Catherine Heller v. Bast and Rood Architects
2014-0853/27/2014State v. Ann-Marie Whiteway
2013-2084/8/2014State v. Allen Spaulding
2013-0454/8/2014State v. Phillip Morse
2013-2364/24/2014Leroy Goodwin v. Andrew Pallito
2013-3935/8/2014Diane Levin v. Douglas C. Walker
2013-4485/8/2014Kenneth P. Felis v. Vicki-Lee Felis
2013-4155/8/2014Suzanne E. Blanchard v. Nancy DeLuca
2013-4735/20/2014Dzemila Heco, Kenan Heco & Emir Heco v. Foster Motors, Johnson Controls, et al.
2013-2395/20/2014State v. Aiden Brunner
2013-4205/20/2014Stanley S. Stroup & Sylvia Stroup v. Peter Doran & Peter Doran Landscape Design
2014-1585/21/2014State v. Kyle D. Bolaski
2012-4795/21/2014State v. Neiman W. Groce
2013-0965/21/2014State v. Joshua Fontaine
2013-2805/21/2014In re Nick Manosh
2013-4145/22/2014In re Bilmar Team Cleaners
2013-0135/22/2014State v. Patrick Bostwick
2014-0365/22/2014Maple Leaf Farm Association v. Department of Labor & Katherine Kelly
2012-442, 2013-1155/22/2014State v. Daniel Pettitt
2013-4346/11/2014Eejipp Ala v. Andrew Pallito, Comm. of Dept. of Corrections
2013-4836/11/2014Kristen Port v. Michael Port
2014-0536/11/2014Rebecca Spaulding v. Department of Labor
2014-0407/23/2014In re H.D., Juvenile
2013-4597/23/2014Alan M. Tsefrekas v. Nancy Tsefrekas
2013-3287/23/2014State v. David Leo Edson
2013-4529/9/2014In re B.L.
2014-0419/9/2014Sue Skaskiw & VT Volunteer Servs. for Animal Humane Society v. VT Agency of Agriculture, Dept. for Children & Families, Kristin Haas, Kathleen Smith and Carol Maloney
2014-0829/9/2014In re PRB Docket No. 2012-155
2013-3929/10/2014State v. Gordon Noyes, Jr.
2014-0499/10/2014In re Goddard College A250 Reconsideration
2014-1029/10/2014Garfield Goodrum & Lucille Goodrum v. VT Dept. of Taxes
2014-1399/10/2014Pauline Guntlow and Richard Winterkorn v. Town of Pownal, Board of Adjustment
2013-3569/25/2014State v. Timothy P. Perley
2014-0929/25/2014Thomas W. Chase, Harold Chase & Ralph Chase v. Taft Hill Tree Farm, Inc., Eric S. Scott & Patricia M. Scott
2014-0389/25/2014Jay M. Moody v. Wendy Moody
2013-21510/8/2014Natural Resources Board Land Use Panel v. Donald Dorr, Mgc, Inc. & Dorr Oil, Co.
2014-11610/8/2014Michael Hemond and Tracey Hemond v. Frontier Communications of American, Inc., Vermont Electric Power Co., Inc., Santec, Inc., et al.
2014-02110/9/2014State v. Robert P. Vezina
2014-08710/9/2014Equinox on the Battenkill v. Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance
2014-09810/9/2014Post and Beam Equity Group, LLC & Post and Beam of Mt. Snow LLC v. Sunne Village Development Property Owners' Assn.
2014-05410/30/2014City of Burlington v. Bilmar Team Cleaners, A Vermont Partnership and Margaret Murray, Individually and as Successor to Bilmar Team Cleaners
2014-00710/30/2014Jonathan H. Dodge v. Governor Peter Shumlin
2014-08010/30/2014Kayla L. Herrick v. Edmund Vigneault
2014-04310/30/2014Jesse DeVos v. Kimberly Volk
2013-45310/30/2014Kayla Eaton and Robert Eaton v. Norman E. Watts and Watts Law Firm, P.C.
2013-21010/7/2014State v. Wayne Hutchins
2013-24210/7/2014State v. Charles Madigan
2013-47711/19/2014State v. Adam Winters
2014-10811/18/2014Roxanne Moran v. VT State Retirement Board & VT State Treasurer
2014-14011/18/2014In re Appeal of MDY Taxes, Inc. and Village Car Wash, Inc.
2014-16211/18/2014In re Zaremba Group Act 250 Permit
2014-19211/19/2014In re Request for Jurisdictional Opinion re: Changes in Physical Structures and Use at Burlington International Airport for F-35A
2014-24511/19/2014State of Vermont v. Joseph Mottolese
2014-28311/19/2014In re Stephanie H. Taylor, M.D.
2013-46712/11/2014John C. Stokes v. State
2014-15312/11/2014Robert Jones, Janet Jones & Jean Bombard v. James Hart
2014-19312/11/2014In re Castleton Expansion Renovation Permit
2014-23712/11/2014In re D.C., Juvenile
2014-28712/11/2014In re B.R., Juvenile
2014-34312/11/2014In re O.D., Juvenile
2014-14612/18/2014In re New England Police Benevolent Assn. Petition for Election of Collective Bargaining Representative
2014-24012/18/2014David A. Gauthier v. Keurig Green Mountain, Inc. f/k/a Green Mountain Coffee Roasters, Inc.
2014-34612/18/2014Gwendolyn Hallsmith v. City of Montpelier, William Fraser and Jessie Baker
expand Year of Argument: 2013
2012-2031/15/2013LaFrance Architect d/b/a Lake Architectural, LLC v. Five Point Development South Burlington, LLC
2012-2271/15/2013Adam Cate v. City of Burlington
2012-1951/15/2013Foti Fuels, Inc. & Robert Foti v. Kurrle Corp., Payjack, LLC & James J. Kurrle
2012-0851/15/2013State of Vermont v. Michael Cahill
2012-1921/16/2013In re Estate of Doris H. Fitzsimmons
2012-1661/16/2013Rhonda Cameron Rollo v. David W. Cameron
2012-1341/16/2013State of Vermont v. Corrina Sullivan
2012-1642/21/2013Kelley S. O'Brien v. Catherine Synnott and Fletcher Allen Healthcare
2012-2122/21/2013Michael Hanson-Metayer v. Elizabeth Hanson-Metayer
2012-255, 2012-2962/21/2013State of Vermont v. Jason Burnett
2012-3652/21/2013State of Vermont v. Marek L. Tuma
2012-2832/6/2013Kimberly Kim v. Larry Hone
2012-2682/6/2013Lisa Crown v. Jeffrey W. Lawson
2012-2732/6/2013Bobbi Jo Stellato v. McCurtis Anthony Williams
2012-2443/12/2013State of Vermont v. Zak Winston
2012-3573/12/2013Marcia Ratner v. Village Square at Pico Condominium Owners Assn., et al.
2012-4643/12/2013Ronald E. Pollock & Milton R. Pollock v. Douglas Butler
2012-3363/12/2013Peter Vieta v. Department of Labor
2012-384, 2012-3353/27/2013Sandra J. Murphy, Personal Rep. & Admin. of the Estate of Christopher Murphy v. Sentry Insurance
2012-087, 2012-101, 2012-102, 2012-103, 2012-207, 2012-231, 2012-309 3/27/2013State v. Ronald Medina, Douglas J. Hewitt, Jr., Shane T. Goodrich, Ricardo Ramos, William Abernathy, Tyler J. Hartz, and Jeffrey Gerrow, et al.
2012-1493/27/2013Michelle M. Straw v. Visiting Nurse Assn. and Hospice of VT/NH
2012-2943/27/2013Janet Knutsen v. David M. Dion, Thomas Gardner, David M. Dion Real Estate, Inc., VT Assn. of Realtors, Inc.
2012-2243/28/2013Brownington Center Church of Browington, Vermont, Inc. v. Town of Irasburg
2012-3673/28/2013Loren and Kathryn Hogaboom v. Trevor Jenkins and Town of Milton
2012-3053/28/2013In re Moore Accessory Structure Permit and Use
2012-3614/9/2013Mark Bilodeau v. Cristina Bilodeau
2012-2694/9/2013Julie D. Proia v. Julius M. Proia, Jr.
2012-3404/9/2013In re K.F., Juvenile
2012-4394/23/2013H. Brooke Paige v. State of Vermont, Jim Condos, Secretary of State and Barack Obama
2012-3914/23/2013Progressive Casualty Insurance Co. v. MMG Insurance Co.
2012-4224/23/2013Travia's Inc. and Robert and Jill Mellion v. State of Vermont, Dept. of Taxes
2012-4754/24/2013Judith Meyncke v. Robert Meyncke
2013-213, 2013-0104/24/2013State v. Bryan Wainwright, State v. Matthew E. Wilder
2012-2584/24/2013Rockingham Area Community Land Trust v. Town of Rockingham
2012-1474/25/2013State v. Jason Gorton
2012-4405/7/2013In re Ronald D. Combs
2012-3295/7/2013Matthew Aldrich v. Jennifer Aldrich Haselman
2013-0495/21/2013State v. Brian K. LeClair
2012-3805/21/2013State v. Prison Health Services, Inc.
2012-4475/21/2013Linda P. Spina v. William J. Spina
2012-3205/23/2013Richard Madowitz, Benedict Kohl as Co-Executor of the Estate of Douglas Kohl & Amherst Realty v. The Woods at Killington Owners' Assn.
2012-1865/22/2013State v. Christopher Scott
2013-0126/11/2013Michele Tattoli v. Christopher Colm
2012-4766/11/2013Logan Nutter v. Charles R. Fenoff, Jr.
2012-4086/11/2013Donald D. Dorr d/b/a D. Dorr Septic v. Paul and Debra LaCoste
2012-4786/11/2013Merchants Bank v. Ann M. Furey
2013-0027/10/2013Mary Duggan v. Department of Labor
2012-4017/10/2013Juanita Belleville v. John N. Young
2012-4309/12/2013In re C.B., Juvenile
2013-0419/12/2013Amanda Mallette v. George H. LaFontaine
2013-0069/12/2013Phyliss E. Trout (Brady) v. Daniel Quinn
2013-12910/10/2013State of Vermont v. Jack Wallace
2013-02510/10/2013Nicole Williams v. James McMillan
2013-31310/10/2013Lonnie Chester, Admin. of the Estate of Philomena Weingarten v. Albert J. Weingarten a/k/a Albert Von Weingarten and Mary Weingarten a/k/a Mary Von Weingarten
2013-09910/10/2013John J. Uckele v. Johana Harris, Thomas Harris and Allstate Insurance
2012-24810/3/2013State v. Tiffanie Felix
2012-420 part II10/3/2013Jasmin LeBlanc v. Daniel LeBlanc
2013-17910/3/2013Lisa Patnode
2013-11611/5/2013In re Norman W. Stevens
2013-14011/5/2013State v. Brian Aubuchon
2013-00911/5/2013In re Group Five Investments CU Permit
2013-39811/6/2013Michael R. Buxton v. Springfield Lodge No. 679 and Robert Merrill, Sr.
2013-19311/6/2013Nathan Paine v. Jamie Buffa
2012-41211/6/2013In re Hale Mountain Fish & Game Club
2013-07811/7/2013State v. Edward Nugent
2012-47411/7/2013In re Burt Allen
2013-032, 2013-033, 2013-02611/7/2013Peter M. Norris, Sr. v. Town of Monkton / James Lathrop v. Town of Monkton
2013-08111/19/2013Town of Colchester v. Robert K. Andres
2013-14811/19/2013In re Robert Jones
2013-03411/19/2013In re Ryan Brink
2013-27211/19/2013Amy Gibbons v. Bradley Burns
2013-19911/19/2013Michael Vereline v. Marybeth Vereline
2013-12012/3/2013Rodney W. Demag v. Better Power Equipment, Inc.
2013-18312/3/2013J. Daniel Mahoney, Daniel J. Mahoney, Patrick Mahoney, Mary Ann Kadish, et al. v. Tara, LLC
2013-23512/3/2013Helena G. Murphy v. Patriot Insurance Company
2013-24012/3/2013Andrea Joseph v. Neal Joseph
2013-07712/4/2013Trevor Evans v. Gerard Cote
2013-18412/4/2013In re Ambassador Insurance Company, Inc.
2013-12512/4/2013Linda Stone, Treasurer, Town of Irasburg v. Selectboard, Town of Irasburg
2013-18012/5/2013In re Appeals of ANR Permits in Lowell Mountain Wind Project Stormwater Permits, et al.
2012-17912/5/2013In re Eric Williams
2013-24912/5/2013Luck Brothers, Inc.
2013-28312/17/2013Kimberly Tillotson v. John Kidder
2013-28212/17/2013Misty Bowen v. Terrel Spearman
2013-16612/17/2013Stacey Hoechner v. Ernest C. Hoechner
expand Year of Argument: