Skip to main content
State of Vermont Judiciary
Court Information
Judicial Community
Legal Information
Contact Us
Public Education
You are here ► State of Vermont Judiciary > Pages > Court-Opinons-Civil-2002to2005 
 
Go Search

 

Vermont Judiciary

Civil Division Opinions 2002 - 2005


Vermont Supreme Court
To view an Opinion click on the Title
TitlePlaintiffDefendantNo.Mo.Yr.CityKindJudgeFiledTopic ATopic BTopic CReview
expand Year Filed: 2005
ZampieriZampieriPrice Chopper Operating Co.5110805WncvToor, Helen M.12/20/2005TortsCivil ProEvidence
MorrisseyMorrisseyCarroll3271003BncvWesley, John P.12/20/2005Civil ProTorts
MeehanMeehanCaponigro1290603OecvTeachout, Mary Miles12/15/2005PropertyTortsCivil Pro
OrlykOrlykSessions, Keiner & Dumont182--04AncvKatz, Matthew I.12/09/2005Civil ProAttorneysRemedies
Ran-Mar, Inc.Ran-Mar, Inc.City of Barre3780602WncvToor, Helen M.11/30/2005AttorneysTaxationCivil Pro
GladstoneGladstoneStuart Cinemas, Inc.6100BncvWesley, John P.11/21/2005Civil ProRemedies
BartusBartusOwl's Nest1690304RdcvNorton, Richard W.11/18/2005Civil ProConstitution
CollinsCollinsThomas336703WmcvWesley, John P.11/04/2005TortsCivil Pro
CooleyCooleyState4030797WncvToor, Helen M.10/27/2005PrisonersAttorneysConstitution
HyundaiHyundai Motor Am.Bagley5751004WncvToor, Helen M.09/27/2005OtherTaxation
FraserFraserSleeper2840504WncvToor, Helen M.09/20/2005Crim. LawStatutesCivil Pro2007 VT 78
PerronNorthern Security Ins. Co.Perron3140696WncvToor, Helen M.09/09/2005InsuranceContractsCivil Pro
RoseRoseCity of BurlingtonS1480--03CncvNorton, Richard W.08/31/2005ContractsGovernmentStatutes
CobeoCobeoEstate of EvansS0547--04CncvNorton, Richard W.08/31/2005TortsProperty
ViensViensDelphia6271103WncvKatz, Matthew I.08/23/2005ContractsAttorneysStatutes
Trowell TradesTrowell Trades Supply, Inc.Fineline Drywall, Inc.S1528--04CncvNorton, Richard W.08/19/2005Civil ProStatutes
DinermanDinermanSantiago5050904WncvKatz, Matthew I.08/17/2005Contracts
SparksSparksHoffmanS0367--05CncvNorton, Richard W.08/04/2005Prisoners
Investors Corp.Investors Corp. of Vt.Bayer AG1011--04CncvNorton, Richard W.08/03/2005Civil ProConstitution
FingerlakesFingerlakes Constr. Co.Fillmore Farms, LLC560204BncvCarroll, Karen R.08/03/2005Civil ProContracts
SherwoodSherwood Dev. Corp.McCormickS1519--04CncvNorton, Richard W.08/02/2005ContractsAttorneysCivil Pro
RichmondTown of RichmondCowanS0688--04CncvNorton, Richard W.08/02/2005PropertyHighwaysEnvironment
SeaburgSeaburgPurple880404AncvReiss, Christina C.08/01/2005Civil ProProperty
BlairBlairFrank W. Whitcomb Constr. Corp.498--01CncvNorton, Richard W.07/26/2005GovernmentRemediesStatutes
RushfordIn re RushfordS0290--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.07/22/2005PrisonersAttorneysCrim. Pro
ManningManningGoodyear Tire & Rubber Co.S1087--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.07/20/2005TortsCivil ProEvidence
BessetteBessetteDep't of CorrectionsS0303--05CncvNorton, Richard W.07/20/2005Civil Pro2007 VT 42
LutherLutherChoice Plus of New Eng.4230803WncvKatz, Matthew I.07/15/2005InsuranceContracts
RappaportRappaportBanfield800203WncvKatz, Matthew I.07/14/2005Property
BenoitIn re Benoit730405AncvReiss, Christina C.07/12/2005PrisonersCrim. LawCrim. Pro
WilliamsIn re Williams1658--04CncvNorton, Richard W.07/08/2005PrisonersAttorneysCivil Pro
BlairBlairFrank W. Whitcomb Constr. Corp.498--01CncvNorton, Richard W.07/06/2005GovernmentRemediesStatutes
BrattleboroTown of BrattleboroDeangelo1470405WmcvCarroll, Karen R.06/30/2005GovernmentStatutesOther2006 VT 56
BlairBlairFrank W. Whitcomb Constr. Corp.498--01CncvNorton, Richard W.06/28/2005Civil ProGovernmentTorts
BradyBradyCU York Ins. Co.1223--02CncvNorton, Richard W.06/27/2005Civil ProContractsAttorneysNo. 05-323 (Mar. 2006) (unpub)., No. 06-369 (Mar. 2007).
Lodging NorthLodging North, Inc.Century Partners, LPS0438--04CncvNorton, Richard W.06/24/2005Civil ProProperty
SinhaSinhaTown of ShelburneS0930--04CncvNorton, Richard W.06/23/2005Civil ProConstitutionTaxation
CowlesCowlesSunshineS1158--04CncvNorton, Richard W.06/23/2005ForeclosuresCivil ProNo. 07-036(Nov. 07)(unpubl)
SparkesSparkesNorwich Univ.4840901WncvKatz, Matthew I.06/07/2005TortsContracts
SherwoodSherwood Dev. Corp.McCormickS1519--04CncvNorton, Richard W.06/06/2005ContractsAttorneysCivil Pro
ChompupongChompupongSaigon Le, Inc.S1067--04CncvKatz, Matthew I.06/03/2005ContractsRentals
TruhanTruhanBailey1520303WncvKatz, Matthew I.06/01/2005GovernmentStatutes
Investors Corp.Investors Corp. of Vt.Bayer AG1011--04CncvNorton, Richard W.06/01/2005Civil ProTortsStatutes
KinoianIn re KinoianS0658--03CncvNorton, Richard W.05/26/2005PrisonersAttorneysNo. 05-232 (Mar. 2006) (unpub)
RichardsRichardsWilliamstown Sch. Bd.1260704OecvDavenport, Amy M.05/25/2005GovernmentAdmin LawCivil Pro
9.6 Shares of StockIn re 9.6 Shares of StockS1172--04CncvNorton, Richard W.05/25/2005ContractsStatutesOther
Hayes FamilyHayes Family P'shipSmartS0520--03CncvNorton, Richard W.05/24/2005Property
HopperHopperState5090904WncvKatz, Matthew I.05/16/2005TaxationAdmin LawCivil Pro
M.O.C.M.O.C., Inc.Main St. Landing Co.S0720--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/10/2005Civil ProContractsTorts
R & G PropertiesR & G PropertiesColumn Financial566--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/05/2005ContractsStatutes2008 VT 113
CodyCodyCody5250904WncvKatz, Matthew I.05/04/2005Attorneys
RobertsonRobertsonGriswold Offset Printing, Inc.235503WmcvWesley, John P.05/03/2005TortsEmploymentCivil Pro
City of BurlingtonCity of BurlingtonElectronics Hospital, Inc.616--03CncvNorton, Richard W.04/27/2005ContractsRentalsStatutes
GloverIn re Glover281--03CncvNorton, Richard W.04/22/2005PrisonersAttorneysEvidence
PrattIn re Leo Pratt980--04CncvNorton, Richard W.04/21/2005PrisonersCrim. ProCrim. Law
FinovaFinova Capital Corp.Hotel Pharmacy, Inc.5581203WmcvCarroll, Karen R.04/19/2005Civil ProContracts
WertWertMesesickS1330--00CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/07/2005Evidence
WorthenWorthenGaulin1546--03CncvNorton, Richard W.03/31/2005EmploymentStatutesTorts
PricePriceTeafordS0908--04CncvNorton, Richard W.03/23/2005Probate Ct.Contracts2006 VT 62
N. Bennington Sch. DistN. Bennington Sch. DistMount Anthony Union High School Dist. No. 142340704BncvCarroll, Karen R.03/15/2005Civil ProGovernmentTaxation
TrickettTrickettOchs2671100AncvReiss, Christina C.03/10/2005TortsEvidenceEnvironmentNo. 05-547 (Jan. 2007).
LothropLothropChirob, Inc.S1051--03CncvNorton, Richard W.03/04/2005Civil ProContractsTorts
LesageLesageTown of Colchester1417--03CncvNorton, Richard W.02/17/2005Admin LawPropertyTaxation
Green Mountain PropaneGreen Mountain Propane GasKimballS0486--01CncvNorton, Richard W.02/16/2005ContractsInsuranceRemedies
LeClaireIn re LeClaireS0998--03CncvNorton, Richard W.02/11/2005PrisonersConstitutionCrim. ProNo. 08-028 (Feb. 4 2009) (unpubl).
HuminskiHuminskiWright51098BncvCarroll, Karen R.02/10/2005Civil ProTortsGovernment
FloodFloodGeorge4240803WncvKatz, Matthew I.02/08/2005TortsCivil Pro
EvartsEvartsOne Beacon Ins. Co.2371104AncvReiss, Christina C.02/02/2005Civil ProInsuranceWork. Comp.
JohnsonJohnsonAgency of Transp.1004--03CncvNorton, Richard W.01/31/2005Civil ProGovernmentStatutes
FitzgeraldFitzgeraldBaker1566--04CncvNorton, Richard W.01/25/2005ConstitutionCivil ProContracts
PentoneyPentoneyStratton Corp.1560403WmcvWesley, John P.01/21/2005TortsCivil Pro
MitecNorthern Security Ins. Co.Mitec Elecs., Ltd.S1167--99CncvKatz, Matthew I.01/11/2005Civil ProInsurance2008 VT 96
DannenbergDannenbergMartinS0475--02CncvNorton, Richard W.01/10/2005TortsAttorneysCivil Pro
expand Year Filed: 2004
WheelerIn re Wheeler2640603WrcvTeachout, Mary Miles12/30/2004Civil ProProbate Ct.
LeClaireIn re LeClaireS0998--03CncvNorton, Richard W.12/28/2004PrisonersAttorneys
FullertonFullertonAmblo1286--04CncvNorton, Richard W.12/22/2004Sm. ClaimsContractsStatutes
TrudoTrudoMeguiar's, Inc.S1474--01CncvNorton, Richard W.12/20/2004Civil ProTorts
TrudoTrudoGrandview Acres Condo Assoc.1211--04CncvNorton, Richard W.12/10/2004Sm. ClaimsEvidenceRemedies
EarleEarleStateS0272--01CncvNorton, Richard W.12/07/2004Civil ProGovernmentTorts2006 VT 92
NummelinNummelinHuneck380203CacvTeachout, Mary Miles11/29/2004Civil ProProperty
PalmeriPalmeriBrattleboro Mem'l Hosp., Inc.2880604WmcvCarroll, Karen R.11/23/2004Civil ProTortsWork. Comp.
Inn at Willow PondInn at Willow PondVermont Carpet2710802BncvCarroll, Karen R.11/22/2004Civil ProTortsRemedies
DavisonDavisonCaleidoscope Communication Co.436--04CncvNorton, Richard W.11/08/2004Civil ProContracts
SadlerSadlerLetourneau757--04CncvNorton, Richard W.11/05/2004Civil ProEvidence
LeachLeachFletcher Allen Health Care, Inc.S0125--02CncvNorton, Richard W.11/01/2004TortsEvidence
Democratic PartyVt. Democratic PartyRepublican Governors Ass'nS1285--04CncvNorton, Richard W.10/26/2004GovernmentRemedies
TangoTango Props.WillisS1501--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.10/15/2004RentalsContractsRemedies
HeddenHeddenTown of HinesburgS0213--03CncvNorton, Richard W.09/28/2004GovernmentHighways
Munson Earth MovingMunson Earth MovingHolmbergS0407--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.09/20/2004Civil ProStatutesRemedies
Main St. LandingMain St. Landing LLCLake St. Assocs., Inc.S0494--04CncvKatz, Matthew I.09/07/2004PropertyContracts2006 VT 13
NobleNobleKalangesS0878--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.08/31/2004PropertyContractsRemedies
OrusevicOrusevicFletcher AllenS0037--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.08/23/2004EvidenceAttorneys
KilburnIn re KilburnS0241--04CncvKatz, Matthew I.08/10/2004PrisonersCrim. Pro
TowneIn re TowneS1222--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.08/06/2004PrisonersCivil ProCourts
KoplewitzKoplewitzHamilton1030201WmcvWesley, John P.07/29/2004TortsEvidence
LarrowEstate of LarrowVincentS1507--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.07/19/2004TortsCivil Pro
TremblayTremblayWesco, Inc.S0358--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.07/14/2004ContractsRentals
Shelburne SupermarketIn re Shelburne SupermarketS0065--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.06/28/2004Civil ProRemediesOther2010 VT 30
PrattIn re PrattS0844--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.06/10/2004PrisonersCrim. Law
EndresEndresEndresS1584--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/27/2004Torts2006 VT 108, 2008 VT 124
MorrisMorrisGoldsmithS1559--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/13/2004ContractsEvidenceOther
MahoneyMahoneyHoweS0890--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/04/2004ContractsPropertyStatutes
LabountyLabountyCrystal Rock Spring Water Co.6101202WrcvTeachout, Mary Miles04/29/2004EmploymentContractsCivil Pro
CunninghamCunninghamDiemerS0467--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/28/2004ContractsRemedies
ProvostProvostFAHCS1573--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/21/2004TortsCivil ProEvidence2005 VT 115
MishkitMishkitWhitneyS0227--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/16/2004Sm. ClaimsTorts
MitecNorthern Security Ins. Co.Mitec Elecs., Ltd.S1167--99CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/13/2004InsuranceContracts2008 VT 96
BrooksBrooksTown of CharlotteS1011--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/12/2004Civil ProNo. 04-227 (Jan. 2005) (unpub.)
RobbinsRobbinsOld Tavern at Grafton, Inc.5951102WrcvTeachout, Mary Miles04/05/2004Civil ProEmploymentContractsNo. 04-203 (Jan. 2005) (unpub.)
RichardsonStateRichardsonS0979--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/01/2004Civil Pro
WilliamsWilliamsCampbellS0920--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.03/12/2004ContractsAttorneys
PetersPetersBenway's Transp.S0793--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.03/11/2004Civil ProStatutesNo. 04-148 (Sep. 2004) (unpub)
Vt. Gas Sys.Vt. Gas Sys.Riser Mgmt. Sys.S1185--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.03/08/2004TortsRemedies
Le PageLe PageBay Creek P'shipS1021--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.02/26/2004Civil Pro
WilliamsonWilliamson PlumbingStockdaleS1565--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.02/13/2004ContractsEvidenceRemedies
O'BrienIn re O'BrienS1146--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.02/05/2004TaxationAdmin LawProperty
HornbostelHornbostelS. Burlington Sch. Dist.S1502--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.02/04/2004TortsCivil Pro
MorrisMorrisGoldsmithS1559--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.01/27/2004CourtsRemediesConstitution
MilletteIn re MilletteS0368--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.01/23/2004PrisonersConstitutionEvidence
HetmanHetmanLexington Mgmt. Corp.S1225--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.01/15/2004TortsCivil ProEvidence
NewmanNewmanHobbsS1164--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.01/02/2004Civil Pro19 #JuriesRemedies
expand Year Filed: 2003
ProvostProvostMoultonS0409--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.12/29/2003RentalsContracts
FarnumFarnumPrue3880803WmcvCarroll, Karen R.12/19/2003Pub. Records
Sandgate Sch. Dist.Sandgate Sch. Dist.Larsen2710903BncvWesley, John P.11/19/2003Admin LawCivil Pro
HollHollBallard2600603WrcvTeachout, Mary Miles11/10/2003Sm. ClaimsRentals
AndresAndresGoldS0986--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.10/29/2003Admin LawConstitutionPrisoners
Shelburne SupermarketIn re Shelburne SupermarketS0065--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.10/22/2003ContractsCivil ProRemedies
Vt. HuntersVt. Hunters, AnglersWinooski Valley Park Dist.S0258--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.10/06/2003GovernmentStatutesProperty
TravelersTravelers Ins. Cos.Demarle, Inc. USAS0826--99CncvKatz, Matthew I.09/22/2003Civil ProContractsEvidence
Prof'l RegulationOffice of Prof'l RegulationBrooks3970701WncvTeachout, Mary Miles08/29/2003Admin LawOther
Universal UnderwritersStateUniversal Underwriters Ins. Co.5390998WncvTeachout, Mary Miles08/20/2003EnvironmentInsurance
Nicom CoatingsNicom Coatings Corp.Acadia Ins. Co.5230802WncvTeachout, Mary Miles07/21/2003Insurance
GoldmanStateGoldman Indus. Group, Inc.8161202WncvTeachout, Mary Miles05/19/2003Environment
GoatworldGoatworld, Ltd.Liquor Control Bd.3250602WncvTeachout, Mary Miles04/17/2003ConstitutionCourts
Downtown BarreDowntown Barre Dev.C & S Wholesale Grocers, Inc.6691002WncvTeachout, Mary Miles03/18/2003ContractsPropertyRentals2004 VT 47
Ford MotorFord Motor Credit Co.Sicely4300702WncvTeachout, Mary Miles02/03/2003Attorneys
expand Year Filed: 2002
GavinGavinBlouin7711100WncvTeachout, Mary Miles12/11/2002Property
PollinaIn re Petition of Pollina6991102WncvTeachout, Mary Miles11/05/2002GovernmentOther