Skip to main content
State of Vermont Judiciary
Court Information
Judicial Community
Legal Information
Contact Us
Public Education
Representing Yourself
You are here ► State of Vermont Judiciary > Pages > Court-Opinons-Civil-2002to2005 
 
Go Search

 

Vermont Judiciary

Civil Division Opinions 2002 - 2005


Vermont Supreme Court
To view an Opinion click on the Title
TitlePlaintiffDefendantNo.Mo.Yr.CityKindJudgeFiledTopic ATopic BTopic CReview
expand Year Filed: 2005
SahlmanSahlmanLane8131202WncvKatz, Matthew I.2/23/2005
NinevahNinevahLorentz1980305RdcvNorton, Richard W.12/23/2005PropertyCivil Pro
BordenBordenRose3611005BncvWesley, John P.12/20/2005CourtsTortsCivil Pro
A & SStateA & S Collection Assocs., Inc.5210805WncvToor, Helen M.12/16/2005Statutes
OTT Rutland, LLCOTT Rutland, LLCDep't of Taxes5560905WncvToor, Helen M.12/14/2005TaxationAdmin LawStatutesNo. 06-308 (Nov. 06)(unpubl).
Ran-Mar, Inc.Ran-Mar, Inc.Town of Berlin1990401WncvToor, Helen M.11/30/2005AttorneysTaxationTorts
TorresTorresEd Thomas Autos and Leasing, Inc.4480804WncvKatz, Matthew I.11/23/2005Civil ProConstitutionContracts
MakedonijaStateMakedonija Tabak 20003720704WncvToor, Helen M.11/18/2005ContractsGovernmentRemedies
Terry's TipsStateTerry's Tips, Inc.5600905WncvToor, Helen M.11/16/2005Admin LawCivil ProStatutes
Nurse W.In re Subpoena Pertaining to Nurse W.6341005WncvToor, Helen M.11/01/2005StatutesEvidence
BergeBergeState3420602WncvToor, Helen M.09/29/2005Property2006 VT 116
KemperKemperForbes356805WmcvWesley, John P.09/21/2005Pub. Records
AhernAhernMackey160104WncvToor, Helen M.09/19/2005Admin LawCivil ProGovernment2007 VT 27
BanknorthBanknorth, N.A.LittlefieldS0273--03CncvNorton, Richard W.09/01/2005ContractsTortsStatutes
CharleboisCharleboisLiberty Mut. Ins. GroupS0488--04CncvNorton, Richard W.08/31/2005Insurance
AlberinoAlberinoBalch5821000WncvKatz, Matthew I.08/24/2005PropertyEnvironmentRemedies2008 VT 130
RichIn re RichS0433--03CncvNorton, Richard W.08/22/2005PrisonersAttorneys
BlackwoodBlackwoodCampbellS0665--05CncvNorton, Richard W.08/18/2005Civil Pro
WateringWatering II, LLCSpeed Channel, Inc.1820603BncvCarroll, Karen R.08/05/2005Attorneys
ClarkClarkProgressive Ins. Co.S0480--03CncvNorton, Richard W.08/04/2005Civil ProInsuranceTaxation
MadkourMadkourZoltak1140304BncvCarroll, Karen R.08/03/2005Civil ProProperty2007 VT 14
Dep't of TaxesDep't of TaxesMarshallS0819--04CncvNorton, Richard W.08/02/2005Civil Pro
RichmondTown of RichmondCowanS0688--04CncvNorton, Richard W.08/02/2005PropertyTortsEnvironment
SebringSebringEllenbogen3241003BncvCarroll, Karen R.08/01/2005Civil ProTortsRemedies
TravelersTravelers Indemnity Co.DeguiseS1253--04CncvNorton, Richard W.07/27/2005InsuranceRentalsContracts2006 VT 87
FitzgeraldFitzgeraldDanaherS0225--04CncvKatz, Matthew I.07/25/2005ContractsRemedies
DesrochersIn re Desrochers1494--03CncvNorton, Richard W.07/22/2005PrisonersCivil ProCrim. Law
PaynePayneU.S. AirwaysS0596--02CncvNorton, Richard W.07/20/2005Civil ProOther2009 VT 90
CoghlanCoghlanConcord Gen. Mut. Ins. Co.S0184--03CncvNorton, Richard W.07/20/2005Civil ProInsurance
Pro'f NursesProf'l Nurses Serv., Inc.Smith7321204WncvKatz, Matthew I.07/14/2005Pub. RecordsStatutes
EganEganDep't of TaxesS1552--04CncvNorton, Richard W.07/14/2005Civil ProAdmin LawTaxation
BlairBlairState5460900WncvKatz, Matthew I.07/11/2005TortsGovernmentCourts
BertelsonBertelsonSunbeam Products, Inc.S0312--04CncvNorton, Richard W.07/07/2005InsuranceTortsCivil Pro
JohnsonJohnsonGorczykS1404--00CncvNorton, Richard W.07/06/2005Prisoners
Reininger-SeverinReininger-SeverinHardyS0015--03CncvNorton, Richard W.06/30/2005EvidenceInsurance
Ran-Mar, Inc.Ran-Mar, Inc.Town of Berlin4990904WncvKatz, Matthew I.06/27/2005TaxationStatutesConstitution2006 VT 117
AtkinsAtkinsBachand894--03CncvNorton, Richard W.06/24/2005Civil ProEvidenceRentals
SheldrakeSheldrakeSkyline Corp.S1269--01CncvNorton, Richard W.06/23/2005Civil ProContractsTorts
Chelsea CommonsChelsea Commons Cmty. Ass'nACM Assocs.S0401--04CncvNorton, Richard W.06/23/2005Civil ProRemedies
MailleMailleDarcy Group, Ltd.S1416--03CncvNorton, Richard W.06/13/2005Contracts
WorthenWorthenGaulin1546--03CncvNorton, Richard W.06/06/2005Civil ProEvidenceStatutes
Mallets Bay HomeownersMallets Bay Homeowners' Ass'nMongeon Bay Props., LLC1216--04CncvNorton, Richard W.06/03/2005Civil ProPropertyRemedies2008 VT 62
WilliamsIn re Williams1658--04CncvNorton, Richard W.06/02/2005PrisonersAttorneysCivil Pro
Investors Corp.Investors Corp. of Vt.Bayer AG1011--04CncvNorton, Richard W.06/01/2005Civil ProStatutes
Munson Earth MovingMunson Earth MovingHolmbergS0407--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/26/2005Civil ProStatutesRemedies
Sunset CliffSunset Cliff Homeowners Ass'nWater Res. Bd.5510904WncvKatz, Matthew I.05/25/2005Admin LawCivil ProEnvironment2008 VT 84
ReynoldsReynoldsBrosseauS1153--01CncvNorton, Richard W.05/25/2005Civil ProEvidence
FitzgeraldFitzgeraldNaumannS0718--01CncvNorton, Richard W.05/24/2005Civil ProEvidence
HoarHoarAgency of Transp.S0491--02CncvNorton, Richard W.05/24/2005GovernmentHighwaysRemedies2006 VT 98
MaddenIn re Shares of Lee Madden1850401WmcvCarroll, Karen R.05/16/2005OtherPropertyEvidence
BellBellPalmer640402AncvReiss, Christina C.05/09/2005Civil ProStatutes
BakerEstate of BakerUniv. of Vt.2331003OscvMorris, Walter M., Jr.05/05/2005Civil ProTorts
Grand CircleGrand Circle LLCRand389--05CncvNorton, Richard W.05/03/2005Civil ProTortsRemedies
GrandviewGrandview Acres Condo Ass'nTrudo191--05CncvNorton, Richard W.04/28/2005Sm. ClaimsEvidence
MerchantMerchantA & C Enercom965--04CncvNorton, Richard W.04/26/2005Admin LawWork. Comp.Attorneys
WarshowWarshowCrompton Corp.1566--02CncvNorton, Richard W.04/22/2005ConstitutionCivil ProTorts
MasonMasonGoldS1567--04CncvNorton, Richard W.04/21/2005Civil ProPrisoners
HobanHobanState2000405WncvKatz, Matthew I.04/15/2005Civil ProAdmin LawStatutes
RobertsonRobertsonGriswold Offset Printing, Inc.2350503WmcvWesley, John P.04/04/2005EmploymentContractsStatutes
JurnakJurnakAqua Waste Septic Service238703BncvCarroll, Karen R.03/23/2005
LyndeLyndeRoss Envtl. Assocs.4981002WmcvCarroll, Karen R.03/15/2005EvidenceTorts
HammondHammondBerlin City's Vt. Remarketed Autos, Inc.1316--02CncvNorton, Richard W.03/10/2005Civil ProEmploymentStatutes
DannenbergDannenbergMartinS0475--02CncvNorton, Richard W.03/08/2005Civil ProTorts
TannerTannerGold3580604WncvKatz, Matthew I.02/25/2005PrisonersAdmin LawStatutes
MontgomeryMontgomeryDevoid27--03CncvNorton, Richard W.02/16/2005Civil ProTorts
Middlebury EquityMiddlebury Equity Partners, LLCMWJ Siam, Inc.S0391--04CncvKatz, Matthew I.02/15/2005ForeclosuresContractsTorts
SlavingSlavingCendant Mortgage Corp.130104BncvCarroll, Karen R.02/10/2005ForeclosuresPropertyStatutes
TravelersTravelers Indemnity Co.DeguiseS1253--04CncvNorton, Richard W.02/10/2005Civil ProInsuranceRentals2006 VT 87
LunenburgTown of LunenburgSupervisor and Bd. of Governors631000ExcvMorris, Walter M., Jr.02/07/2005GovernmentRemedies2006 VT 71
YohIn re Yoh758--01CncvNorton, Richard W.01/31/2005PrisonersAttorneysCrim. Pro2006 VT 49
Northgate Hous. Ltd.Northgate Hous. Ltd.MassieS1045--03CncvNorton, Richard W.01/31/2005Civil ProAttorneysRentals
LankinLankinStasikS1263--03CncvNorton, Richard W.01/25/2005Evidence
BlakeBlakeNationwide Ins. Co.1200303WmcvCarroll, Karen R.01/13/2005Civil ProInsuranceWork. Comp.2006 VT 48
NormandyNormandyMartinS0278--04CncvNorton, Richard W.01/11/2005Civil ProCrim. LawTorts
RileyRileyDempsey4250804WrcvTeachout, Mary Miles01/05/2005Sm. ClaimsRentals
expand Year Filed: 2004
LoiselleLoiselleBarsalowS0730--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.12/29/2004InsuranceStatutesEvidence2006 VT 61
FucileFucileVisa U.S.A. Inc.1560--03CncvNorton, Richard W.12/27/2004Civil ProTortsStatutes
BanknorthBanknorth, N.A.Zeeman1730304WncvKatz, Matthew I.12/20/2004ContractsCivil ProStatutes
CoutureIn re CoutureS0457--04CncvNorton, Richard W.12/14/2004PrisonersCivil ProStatutesNo. 04-559 (Dec. 2005) (unpub).
MerchantMerchantA & C EnercomS0965--04CncvNorton, Richard W.12/09/2004Civil ProWork. Comp.
FrancoeurFrancoeurAllen950304BncvCarroll, Karen R.12/06/2004Civil ProTortsEvidence
MorrowMorrowMunson945--04CncvNorton, Richard W.11/29/2004Sm. ClaimsRentalsStatutes
BertelsonBertelsonUnion Mut. Fire Ins. Co.834--04CncvNorton, Richard W.11/22/2004InsuranceTortsStatutes
Northgate Hous. Ltd.Northgate Hous. Ltd.White1046--03CncvNorton, Richard W.11/19/2004Civil ProRentalsStatutes
LeachLeachFletcher Allen Health Care, Inc.S0125--02CncvNorton, Richard W.11/08/2004Civil ProTortsStatutes
ShaderShaderShader4020903WmcvCarroll, Karen R.11/03/2004PropertyTortsRemedies
Democratic PartyVt. Democratic PartyRepublican Governors Ass'nS1285--04CncvNorton, Richard W.10/29/2004GovernmentRemedies
SheddSheddGuerraS0863--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.10/18/2004Civil ProTortsNo. 05-051 (Aug 2005) (unpub)
ParahParahLakeside Pharmacy, Inc.S0195--02CncvNorton, Richard W.09/30/2004TortsEvidence
RoweRoweLavanwayS1159--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.09/22/2004PropertyEvidence2006 VT 47
DiLelloDiLelloUnion Tools, Inc.S0149--02CncvNorton, Richard W.09/15/2004Civil ProEvidence
TrudoTrudoMeguiar's, Inc.S1474--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.08/31/2004Civil ProConstitution
LaddIn re LaddS1510--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.08/31/2004PrisonersCivil ProStatutesNo. 04-442 (May 2005)(unpub)
Gregory SupplyGregory Supply Co.CalacciS0585--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.08/11/2004ContractsRemedies
JaffeJaffeKolokS1130--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.08/10/2004ContractsRemediesOther
N. Hero MarinaN. Hero MarinaMelansonS0607--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.07/30/2004TortsStatutesAttorneys
TurmelTurmelUniv. of Vt.S0980--04CncvKatz, Matthew I.07/20/2004TortsCivil Pro
ScribnerIn re ScribnerS0841--00CncvKatz, Matthew I.07/15/2004PrisonersCrim. ProCivil Pro
KurrelmeyerIn re Kurrelmeyer EstateS1079--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.07/14/2004Probate Ct.2006 VT 19, 2010 VT 20
ConcordConcord Gen. Mut. Ins. Co.Madore5071103WmcvCarroll, Karen R.06/17/2004Civil ProInsurance2005 VT 70
HerbertHerbertPico Ski AreaS1268--00CncvKatz, Matthew I.06/08/2004ContractsCivil Pro2006 VT 74
Sunset CliffSunset Cliff Homeowners Ass'nWater Res. Bd.S0187--04CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/17/2004Admin LawEnvironmentStatutes
DiLelloDiLelloUnion Tools, Inc.S0149--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/13/2004TortsCivil Pro
HetmanHetmanLexington Mgmt. Corp.S1225--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/04/2004TortsCivil ProEvidence
BeemanBeemanNesbitt5031103WmcvCarroll, Karen R.04/28/2004Civil ProContractsRemedies
AndersonAndersonDorschS1390--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/22/2004AttorneysContractsTorts
TurmelTurmelUniv. of Vt.S0980--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/20/2004TortsCivil Pro
Vt. Teddy BearVt. Teddy Bear Corp.GawrysS1392--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/15/2004Civil ProEmploymentRemedies
LussierLussierArmstrongS0981--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/12/2004TortsCivil ProEvidence
Summits 7Summits 7, Inc.LaskerS1328--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/07/2004ContractsEmployment2005 VT 97
WatsonWatsonDimkeS1497--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/05/2004EvidenceStatutesCivil Pro2005 VT 29
SheldrakeSheldrakeSkyline Corp.S1269--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.03/29/2004Civil ProRemedies
LussierLussierArmstrongS0981--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.03/11/2004TortsCivil ProEvidence
CheseryCheseryZenoS1268--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.03/08/2004ContractsEvidenceAttorneys
NelsonNelsonWickS0322--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.03/03/2004AttorneysTortsRemedies
BradshawIn re BradshawS1565--98CncvKatz, Matthew I.02/17/2004PrisonersAttorneysCrim. Pro
Hersheldon'sHersheldon'sCensor SecurityS0327--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.02/12/2004TortsCivil Pro
BissonetteBissonetteSouthland Log Homes, Inc.S0901--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.02/04/2004ContractsRemedies
HutchinsHutchinsPeterson4801000WmcvWesley, John P.01/30/2004Civil ProCrim. ProGovernment
CPI ControlsCPI Controls, Inc.IBM Corp.S0483--02CncvKatz, Matthew I.01/27/2004Civil ProContractsRemedies
SkibaSkibaWhitcombS1232--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.01/21/2004AttorneysEvidence
WilliamsWilliamsCampbellS0920--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.01/07/2004ContractsAttorneys
expand Year Filed: 2003
ReynoldsReynoldsBrosseauS1153--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.12/29/2003ContractsPropertyCivil Pro
KaeslerKaeslerSchulzS0880--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.12/23/2003PropertyRemediesOther
Our Lady of EphesusOur Lady of Ephesus House of Prayer, Inc.Town of Jamaica4400902WmcvWesley, John P.12/05/2003Taxation2005 VT 16
RobinsonRobinsonHodgdon Bros., Inc.1100300WrcvTeachout, Mary Miles11/17/2003Work. Comp.
MattoonIn re MattoonS0822--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.10/30/2003Probate Ct.Evidence
VoVoLeoS0845--03CnscKatz, Matthew I.10/22/2003Sm. ClaimsContractsTorts
DaceyDaceyHomestead DesignS0014--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.10/22/2003ContractsTortsRemedies
Maint. Mgmt.Maint. Mgmt.PelinoS1345--01CncvKatz, Matthew I.09/25/2003ContractsRemediesStatutes
Shelburne SupermarketIn re Shelburne SupermarketS0065--03CncvKatz, Matthew I.09/11/2003ContractsCivil ProRemedies
DasilvaIn re Dasilva8191202WncvTeachout, Mary Miles08/29/2003Admin LawOther
SmithSmithCentral Vermont Hospital, Inc.3060601WncvTeachout, Mary Miles07/30/2003Torts2004 VT 113
MarbleMarbleFirst Am. Flood Data Servs., Inc.870201WncvTeachout, Mary Miles07/14/2003Civil ProTortsNo. 03-428 (June 2004) (unpub.)
RappaportRappaportBanfield800203WncvTeachout, Mary Miles05/01/2003Property
SessionsSessionsState390199WncvTeachout, Mary Miles04/15/2003GovernmentTortsEmployment
MarshallMarshallReynells Co., Inc.1170301WncvTeachout, Mary Miles03/18/2003Torts
LawsonLawsonBrown's Home Day Care Ctr., Inc.1950997CacvTeachout, Mary Miles01/29/2003Attorneys2004 VT 61
expand Year Filed: 2002
KontosKontosState1220300WncvTeachout, Mary Miles12/06/2002Civil ProGovernmentTorts
BergeronBergeronBoyle990--99CncvTeachout, Mary Miles05/21/2002Civil ProPropertyRemedies2003 VT 89