Skip to main content
State of Vermont Judiciary
Court Information
Judicial Community
Legal Information
Contact Us
Public Education
You are here ► State of Vermont Judiciary > Pages > Court-Opinons-Civil-2006to2010 
 
Go Search

 

Vermont Judiciary

Civil Division Opinions 2006 - 2010


Vermont Supreme Court
To view an Opinion click on the Title
TitlePlaintiffDefendantNo.Mo.Yr.CityKindJudgeFiledTopic ATopic BTopic CReview
expand Year Filed: 2010
HicksHicksLiberty Mut. Group, Inc.550810WrcvHayes, Katherine A.12/27/2010
LattucaLattucaSilver605809RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles12/15/2010
O'ConnorO'ConnorDonovanS017310CncvToor, Helen M.12/13/2010
PricePriceBowen6511000RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles11/24/2010
CarrollTom Carroll Elec. Constr., LLCWard290610WmcvWesley, John P.11/12/2010
GallowayGallowayTown of Hartford473810WrcvHayes, Katherine A.11/08/2010
WoodWoodPallito9471209WncvCrawford, Geoffrey11/03/2010
ReaReaTownsend261409WrcvEaton, Harold E.10/28/2010
BeyorIn re: Scott Beyor457609RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles10/26/2010
VaneIn re Arbitration Before Leo G. BissonS072410CncvToor, Helen M.10/25/2010
NobleNobleSec'y of State48910ExcvManley, M. Kathleen10/21/2010
RABRAB Performance RecoveriesSwansonS217109CnscToor, Helen M.10/20/2010
McCartyGMAC Mortgage, LLCMcCartyS154309CncvToor, Helen M.10/13/2010
MunsonMunson Earth Moving Corp.City of South BurlingtonS034609CncvToor, Helen M.10/12/2010
CSWDIn re Acquisition by Chittenden Solid Waste Dist. of Certain Prop. Interests by Eminent DomainS105492CncvToor, Helen M.10/05/2010
NamiotIn re: Estate of Lisa L. Namiot351510RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles09/17/2010
QueiroloQueiroloHighridge Condo. Owners Ass'n200307RdcvCohen, William09/01/2010
MillerMillerCity of Rutland513710RdcvCohen, William08/19/2010
AdamsAdamsCitizens Auto Fin., Inc.466608RdcvCohen, William08/18/2010
SchreckSchreckBlack River Brewing Co.6431007WrcvEaton, Harold E.08/10/2010
BandlerBandlerCharter One Bank451703RdcvCohen, William08/02/2010
Gilbert-CohenGilbert-CohenCarthage Area Hospital, Inc.20110WmcvWesley, John P.06/28/2010
GuadalupeOur Lady of Guadalupe Home Found., Inc.Massucco203309RdcvCohen, William06/22/2010
TrinderTrinderConn. Attorneys Title Ins. Co.681908RdcvCohen, William06/07/2010
DoeDoeVermont Office of Health AccessS035507CncvToor, Helen M.05/17/2010
AbeytaAbeytaHolmberg607809RdcvCohen, William05/13/2010
HanerHanerState290707BncvWesley, John P.05/12/2010
FAHCFletcher Allen Health CareClappS100109CncvToor, Helen M.05/11/2010
ForestdaleForestdale Heights, Inc.Essex Junction Sch. Dist.S021508CncvToor, Helen M.05/05/2010
RasmussenRasmussenHuntington2301109OecvDevine, Thomas J.05/04/2010
MuhammadIn re Joshua MuhammadS018508CncvToor, Helen M.04/28/2010
N.H. HydraulicsN.H. Hydraulics, Inc.Crean Equip., Inc.669909RdcvCohen, William04/26/2010
LenociLenociLeonard604808RdcvEaton, Harold E.04/15/2010
KimballKimballState562808WrcvEaton, Harold E.04/14/2010
HartHartChaves Londonderry Gravel Pit, LLC464909WmcvWesley, John P.04/07/2010
VladykaVladykaMarsh266409RdcvCohen, William03/31/2010
PerryIn re: Estate of Farwell W. Perry9871209RdcvCohen, William03/23/2010
RJ ReynoldsState of VermontR. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co.S108705CncvPearson, Dennis R.03/10/2010
WellfordWellfordEissmann7471009WrcvEaton, Harold E.03/09/2010
American IndoorAmerican Indoor Air Quality Assessment Services, Ltd.The Ozone Man, Inc.207909OecvDevine, Thomas J.03/05/2010
AldenEstate of Nancy B. AldenDee4271206BncvWesley, John P.03/03/20102010 VT 3
DanielsDanielsThe Elks Club of Hartford, Vt., Inc.49109WrcvEaton, Harold E.02/26/2010
HechanovaState of Vermont Department of TaxesHechanovaS029509CncvToor, Helen M.02/22/2010
PascarellaPascarellaPerry709909RdcvCohen, William02/22/2010
LackeyLackeyCmty. Health Care, Inc.169307WmcvWesley, John P.02/18/2010
WilcoxWilcoxWilcox96306BncvSuntag, David02/18/2010
HenselderHenselderTown of Castleton556708RdcvCohen, William02/12/2010
G.R. Tech., Inc.G.R. Tech., Inc.Casella Waste Sys., Inc.503708RdcvEaton, Harold E.02/10/2010
BarrabyBarrabyVt. State Employees Ass'n342605WncvCrawford, Geoffrey02/01/2010
HoweHowe Center, Ltd.Suburban Propane, L.P.702908RdcvCohen, William01/28/2010
BostockBostockCity of BurlingtonS133703CncvToor, Helen M.01/27/2010
RhodesIn re Town Highway #20S17397FccvJoseph, Ben W.01/14/2010
expand Year Filed: 2009
In re Norwich Taxpayer AppealsIn re Norwich Taxpayer Appeals7801108WrcvEaton, Harold E.12/24/2009
PrimPrimFisherS146409CncvToor, Helen M.12/22/2009
DernierDernierMary Mitchell Real Estate, LLC635907WrcvEaton, Harold E.12/15/2009
ShermanShermanDucharme334508WrcvEaton, Harold E.11/10/2009
JenkinsUnifund CCR PartnersJenkins158709OecvDevine, Thomas J.11/10/2009
HornbostelHornbostelMartin40708GicvRainville, A. Gregory10/29/2009
BischoffCitiMortgage, Inc.Bischoff255409RdcvCohen, William10/28/2009
PerkinsHousehold Fin. Corp. IIPerkins9721208RdcvCohen, William10/28/2009
MERSMortgage Elec. Registration Sys., Inc. (MERS)Johnston420609RdcvCohen, William10/28/2009
DanielsDanielsThe Elks Club of Hartford, Vt., Inc.49109WrcvEaton, Harold E.10/23/2009
WymanU.S. Bank Nat'l Ass'nWyman466609RdcvCohen, William10/20/2009
PfeiferPfeiferBlakeS023608CncvToor, Helen M.10/15/2009
KepplerKepplerRoman Catholic Diocese of Burlington, VermontS093005CncvToor, Helen M.09/25/2009
MunsonMunsonState of VermontS056808CncvToor, Helen M.09/21/2009
SchreckSchreckNitka580808WrcvEaton, Harold E.09/15/2009
DanielsDanielsThe Elks Club of Hartford, Vt., Inc.49109WrcvEaton, Harold E.09/14/2009
HaganHaganCity of Barre320509WncvToor, Helen M.09/04/2009
CadyCadyGen. Elec. Co.218308RdcvCohen, William08/13/2009
Rutland Plywood Corp.Rutland Plywood Corp.Maass317505RdcvCohen, William08/06/2009
BukerBukerKing5231105WrcvEaton, Harold E.08/05/2009
LaneIn re: Edward Lane192808OecvTeachout, Mary Miles07/22/2009
ReynoldsReynoldsSnader6791007WrcvEaton, Harold E.07/10/2009No. 2009-279 (10/21/10) (unpub).
EllmanEllmanSpruce Peak Realty, LLC195808LecvReiss, Christina06/26/2009
Advance MagazineAdvance Magazine Publishers, Inc.Anichini, Inc.150608OecvDiMauro, Theresa S.06/26/2009
RoyRoySeager184308RdcvCohen, William06/22/2009
ThomasConcord Gen. Mut. Ins. Co.Thomas8161207RdcvCohen, William05/27/2009
MartinMartinVt. Dep't of Taxes8181108WrcvEaton, Harold E.05/14/2009
ShahiShahiDonnelly496906WrcvEaton, Harold E.05/07/2009
Advance MagazineAdvance Magazine Publishers, Inc.Anachini, Inc.150608OecvDiMauro, Theresa S.04/15/2009
SearsburgTown of SearsburgState of Vt., Dep't of Educ.6901008WncvToor, Helen M.03/30/2009
PaigePaigeFahey133508OecvTeachout, Mary Miles03/19/2009
JoyceJoyceStevens5651105WrcvEaton, Harold E.03/11/2009
ChaseChaseState211406WncvToor, Helen M.03/06/20092008 VT 107
MascomaMascoma Savings Bank, FSBNiteen Hotels (VT) LLC71208WrcvEarton, Harold E.02/26/2009
WoodsWoodsMetzler302606RdcvCohen, William02/13/2009
RobertsRobertsHofmann211408WncvToor, Helen M.02/13/2009
BloomerBloomerLamphere476707RdcvCohen, William02/11/2009
BensonBensonHodgdon291604WrcvEaton, Harold E.02/04/20092010 VT 11
HierHierTown Sch. Dist. of Fair Haven640808RdcvCohen, William02/02/2009
Wilcox (shares)WilcoxWilcox96306BncvSuntag, David01/30/2009
DobbinsDobbinsHofmann6461007WrcvEaton, Harold E.01/09/2009
JohnsonJohnsonHarwood162305WncvToor, Helen M.01/06/2009
expand Year Filed: 2008
Human Rights Comm'nVermont Human Rights Comm’nBenevolent and Protective Order of Elks, Hartford, Vt. Lodge No. 1541404898WncvToor, Helen M.12/29/2008
GreenGreenHofmann7441008WncvToor, Helen M.12/24/2008
HubbardHubbardHubbard499708RdcvCohen, William12/18/2008
CenturyCentury Indem. Co.Parsons Hill P'ship7031007RdcvCohen, William12/10/2008
LakatosLakatosOffice of Prof’l Regulation, Vt. Sec’y of State5881006WncvToor, Helen M.12/03/2008
Northern Sec. Ins.Northern Sec. Ins. Co.Rosenthal8181207WncvToor, Helen M.11/21/20082009 VT 83
LaneIn re Lane Family Trust572708RdcvCohen, William11/18/2008
WhitmoreWhitmorePhillips7701008RdcvCohen, William11/13/2008
HillHillMarkowitz640908WncvToor, Helen M.10/17/2008
MadowitzMadowitzThe Woods at Killington Owners’ Ass’n396702RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles10/10/20082010 VT 37
HarrildHarrildBailey10106OecvTeachout, Mary Miles10/07/2008
CaryeCaryeGranite State Ins. Co.281508WncvToor, Helen M.10/07/2008
DaltoDaltoFactory Point Nat'l Bank506906RdcvCohen, William10/02/2008
MarchBlanche S. March Inter Vivos TrustEfthim338507WrcvEaton, Harold E.09/19/2008
Wilcox (sever)WilcoxWilcox96306BncvSuntag, David09/12/2008
Cajun EnterprisesCajun Enterprises, Inc.Champney2100307WncvToor, Helen M.09/11/2008
Ford MotorFord Motor Credit, LLCPorter86208RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles09/02/2008
P.E.T.E.L.P.E.T.E.L. Properties, Inc.Belock396607RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles08/29/2008
TD BanknorthTD Banknorth, N.A.Lavictoire2107RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles08/27/2008
SawabiniSawabiniBrancheS0262--07CncvKatz, Matthew I.08/11/2008
RanzonaRanzonaGero Bros. Movers671--08CncvKatz, Matthew I.08/08/2008
BloomerBloomerLamphere476707RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles07/31/2008
GionetGionetGibeault’s Body Shop92208RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles07/25/2008
Acadia InsuranceAcadia Ins. Co.L&B Truck Serv., Inc.477907WmcvHoward, David07/18/2008
StateStateHowe Cleaners, Inc.27104WncvTeachout, Mary Miles07/18/2008
StateStateHowe Cleaners, Inc.27104WncvTeachout, Mary Miles07/17/2008
MeulrathMeulrathFisher3107WmcvHoward, David07/16/2008
H.P. CummingsH.P. Cummings Constr. Co.East Shore Drywall, Inc.1495--06CncvKatz, Matthew I.07/14/2008
LemayLemayBessette99204RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles06/06/2008TortsStatutes
Puro and YokenPuro and YokenNeil Enterprises, Inc.531906WrcvMorris, Walter M.05/21/2008ContractsRentalsRemedies2009 VT 95
NaylorNaylorCussonS0142--05CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/20/2008No. 08-327 (Feb. 08) (unpubl).
Birch LedgeBirch Ledge Farm, Inc.KojimaS0954--07CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/19/2008
ButlerButlerVermont Electric Power Co.35107AncvToor, Helen M.05/14/2008Civil Pro
BabelBabelRoman Catholic Diocese of BurlingtonS027405CncvKatz, Matthew I.05/01/2008EvidenceStatutes
BabelBabelRoman Catholic Diocese of BurlingtonS027405CncvKatz, Matthew I.04/24/2008Civil ProStatutes
J.P. Carrera & SonsJ.P. Carrara & Sons, Inc.Shum31107RdscTeachout, Mary Miles04/02/2008Evidence
Northshire BookstoreNorthshire Bookstore Properties, LLCDep't of Taxes102407BncvHoward, David03/27/2008Admin LawTaxationStatutes
ZornZornRyan327705WrcvTeachout, Mary Miles03/21/2008No. 08-445 (Apr. 15, 2009) (unpubl).
LeonenkoLeonenkoEbner210403RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles02/28/2008No. 08-160 (Nov. 2008)(unpubl).
Deutsche BankDeutsche Bank Nat’l Trust Co.Griggs6401106WrcvMorris, Walter02/22/2008ForeclosuresCivil ProRemedies
SawyerSawyerHallock Plumbing125405CncvKatz, Matthew I.01/10/2008Torts
VastanoVastanoKillington Valley Real Estate7511201RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles01/10/20082007 VT 33, 2010 VT 11
expand Year Filed: 2007
ReposaReposaLandon1102--06CncvKatz, Matthew I.12/24/2007
SavageSavageWalker327507RdcvTeachout, Mary Miles12/19/2007Civil ProStatutes2009 VT 8
TurnerTurnerRoman Catholic Diocese of Burlington102004CncvKatz, Matthew I.12/03/2007TortsCivil ProStatutes2009 VT 101
A2A2, Inc.Town of ColchesterS081304CncvKatz, Matthew I.11/26/2007ContractsProperty2009 VT 50
StowellStowellAction Moving & Storage, Inc.S009103CncvKatz, Matthew I.11/21/2007AttorneysRemedies
FullerFullerTown of MiltonS129106CncvKatz, Matthew I.11/08/2007Civil ProTaxationStatutes
ChatotChatotForant and Allaire147304WncvTeachout, Mary Miles09/26/2007Property
CraigCraigELRAC, Inc.970207WncvTeachout, Mary Miles09/04/2007InsuranceCivil Pro
ParkerParkerMaine Mutual Group Ins. Co.180306WncvTeachout, Mary Miles08/30/2007Insurance
StoningtonStateStonington Ins. Co.8111202WncvTeachout, Mary Miles08/02/2007InsuranceEnvironmentStatutes
MBNAMBNA America Bank NAWallace5881206WmcvWesley, John P.07/26/2007CourtsConstitutionStatutes
FlemingFlemingKruziffer Motors, Inc.440906WmcvWesley, John P.07/20/2007ContractsCourtsRemedies
MercandanteMercandanteEastern Industries, Inc.465807WncvTeachout, Mary Miles07/17/2007RentalsContractsStatutes
Great NortheastStateGreat Northeast Productions, Inc229406WncvTeachout, Mary Miles07/05/2007ContractsCivil ProEvidence2008 VT 13
GiordanoB. Richard Giordano Living TrustSmith5411106WmcvWesley, John P.06/28/2007PropertyEvidenceRemedies
Ice CenterIce Center of Washington West, Inc.Town of Waterbury5951006WncvTeachout, Mary Miles06/27/2007TaxationStatutes2008 VT 37
RizziRizziMehuron's Market148305WncvTeachout, Mary Miles05/22/2007TortsCivil Pro
HenryHenryDept. of Taxes6531006WncvTeachout, Mary Miles05/03/2007Admin LawTaxationStatutes
Progressive PlasticsProgressive Plastics, Inc.Peerless Ins. Co.186903OecvTeachout, Mary Miles05/02/2007Admin LawCourtsStatutes
BouchardBouchardGerrish449806WncvTeachout, Mary Miles05/01/2007Property
RouleauRouleauTown of Cabot473806WncvTeachout, Mary Miles04/23/2007EnvironmentGovernmentCivil Pro
Asset AcceptanceAsset Acceptance LLCOtis544906WncvTeachout, Mary Miles04/09/2007CourtsEnforcementRemedies
WindhamTown of WindhamReese5461003WmcvWesley, John P.04/05/2007TortsEnvironmentRemedies
Jeffrey BarnesJeffrey Barnes Architect & Associates, Inc.Sunrise at Bear Mountain, LLC180506BncvWesley, John P.04/02/2007Civil ProContractsCourts
IngersonIngersonState5121204WmcvWesley, John P.03/29/2007PrisonersAttorneysNo. 07-161 (Mar. 08) (unpubl).
IngersonIngersonState5121204WmcvWesley, John P.03/29/2007PrisonersStatutesConstitutionNo. 07-161 (Mar. 08) (unpubl).
SchreinerSchreinerEstate of Schreiner356806WmcvWesley, John P.03/15/2007Probate Ct.StatutesProperty
BotzIn re Guardianship of Botz7641206WncvTeachout, Mary Miles03/15/2007Probate Ct.
TowerIn re Tower6281006WncvTeachout, Mary Miles03/14/2007Civil Pro
Mount SnowMount Snow Grand Summit Hotel and Crown Club Owners Ass'nGrand Summit Resport Properties5641203WmcvWesley, John P.03/01/2007Civil ProContractsRemedies
TD BanknorthTD BanknorthDep't of Taxes2350406WncvTeachout, Mary Miles03/01/2007Admin LawTaxationStatutes2008 VT 120
DuhamelDuhamelDonnelly395705WncvTeachout, Mary Miles02/27/2007Civil ProStatutesProperty
Beck EngineeringBeck EngineeringVermont Wild Hotel, Inc.371806WmcvWesley, John P.02/20/2007Civil ProContractsStatutes
B&F LandB&F Land Development, LLCSteinfeld277705BncvWesley, John P.02/13/2007Civil ProContractsRemedies2008 VT 109
BrenBrenEardensohn320505WncvTeachout, Mary Miles01/22/2007HighwaysEvidenceStatutes
Ford MotorFord Motor Credit Co.Drury475806WncvTeachout, Mary Miles01/18/2007ContractsAttorneys
Cultural IntrigueCultural Intrigue, IncTrapeni2170506WmcvWesley, John P.01/05/2007ContractsRemedies
expand Year Filed: 2006
BhattBhattUniversity of VermontS1491--04CncvKatz, Matthew I.12/22/2006TortsStatutes2008 VT 76
MurphyMurphyMactaw, Inc.S0653--06CncvKatz, Matthew I.12/20/2006Civil ProWork. Comp.
KuesKeusCatamount Restaurant & Bar, Inc.11105BncvWesley, John P.12/19/2006Civil ProTortsStatutes
BaconIn Re Bacon2300506WmcvWesley, John P.11/06/2006ConstitutionCrim. Pro
MorrisonMorrisonPerrotta2920804BncvWesley, John P.10/19/2006Civil ProOther
LoitersteinLoitersteinWoodward3641005BncvWesley, John P.10/10/2006ContractsRemedies
MyersMyersDutton2150506WmcvWesley, John P.09/22/2006ContractsEmploymentStatutes
MeyerMeyerMeier2260406WncvToor, Helen M.08/23/2006AttorneysCivil Pro
BadgleyBadgleyWalton5381102WmcvWesley, John P.08/03/2006ConstitutionGovernmentStatutes
KevanKevanTown of Randolph Selectboard1370705WrcvTeachout, Mary Miles07/31/2006GovernmentStatutesCivil Pro
NelsonIn re Nelson2001005OecvTeachout, Mary Miles07/31/2006PrisonersCrim. Pro
ChaseChaseState2110406WncvToor, Helen M.07/18/2006Civil ProRemedies
PittstownPittstown Beagle ClubHale Mountain Fish and Game Club, Inc.302903BncvWesley, John P.06/08/2006Civil ProContracts
GaboriaultGaboriaultPearson70104CacvMorris, Walter M., Jr.05/16/2006ContractsTortsRemedies
Leader Home CenterLeader Home Center, Inc.Coughlin310604WmcvWesley, John P.04/04/2006Civil ProForeclosures
SpoonerSpoonerTown of Topsham1290704OecvTeachout, Mary Miles03/14/2006ConstitutionEvidenceOther2009 VT 43, 2007 VT 98
Patch'sPatch'sExxon620101RdcvNorton, Richard W.02/22/2006CourtsEnvironmentStatutes
SargoodSargoodSouthwestern Vermont Medical Center, Inc.5105BncvWesley, John P.02/03/2006Civil ProAttorneysEvidence
Furst-McNessFurst-McNess Co.Westminster Farms, Inc.4241005WmcvWesley, John P.02/01/2006Civil ProConstitution
ConeseConeseKasuba4830801RdcvNorton, Richard W.01/26/2006PropertyEnforcementRemedies