Skip to main content
State of Vermont Judiciary
Court Information
Judicial Community
Legal Information
Contact Us
Public Education
Representing Yourself
External Web
You are here ► State of Vermont Judiciary > Court Information > Environmental Division > MasterPages > 2010-PresentOpinions 
Go Search


Environmental Division

Opinions 2010 - Present

Environmental Court

Please note starting April 1,2012 all Opinions posted will be signed.

To view information click on the + next to the year and then the Opinion that you would like to view.
Environmental Case NameDocket NumberDecision DateCountyJudgeAdditional Docket #'s
expand Decision Year: 2016
Remaniak Permit173-12-14 Vtec06/23/2016AddisonHon. Thomas Walsh
Margaret Pratt Assisted Living111-8-14 Vtec06/21/2016OrangeHon. Thomas Durkin112-8-14 Vtec, 13-2-15 Vtec & 100-8-15 Vtec
Killington Village Master Plan Act 250147-10-13 Vtec06/21/2016RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin
ANR v Supeno, et al98-8-15 Vtec06/09/2016AddisonHon. Thomas Walsh
Southerly Side of US Rte 7 LLC135-9-14 Vtec05/27/2016ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
ANR v Branon & Branon Trustees22-2-16 Vtec05/24/2016OrleansHon. Thomas DurkinName change from ANR v Branon
Costco Stormwater Amend84-7-15 Vtec05/09/2016ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
NRB v Stratton Corp.106-7-14 Vtec04/26/2016WindhamHon. Thomas Walsh
N.E, Materials Grp 35-3-13 Vtec04/18/2016WashingtonHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court Appeal 5/18/16
Ossterman Deemed Approval124-10-15 Vtec04/13/2016AddisonHon. Thomas Walsh
Hinesburg Hannaford CU129-9-12 Vtec04/12/2016ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh163-11-12 Vtec, 68-5-14 Vtec,69-5-14 Vtec, 70-5-14 Vtec, 73-5-14 Vtec, 113-8-14 Vtec
Hinesburg Hannaford SD Revision68-5-14 Vtec04/12/2016ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh69-5-14 Vtec, 70-5-14 Vtec, 129-9-12 Vtec, 163-11-12 Vtec, 73-5-14 Vtec, 113-8-14 Vtec
Hinesburg Hannaford Act 250113-8-14 Vtec04/12/2016ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh129-9-12 Vtec, 163-11-12 Vtec, 68-5-14 Vtec, 69-5-14 Vtec, 70-5-14 Vtec, 73-5-14 Vtec
Lawrence Bonneet St Major Dev128-11-15 Vtec03/15/2016BenningtonHon. Thomas Walsh
Killington Resort Parking Project A250 Amendment173-12-13 Vtec03/07/2016RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin
Jericho Market Act 201-1-16 Vtec03/02/2016FranklinHon. Thomas Walsh
Beauregard NOV3-1-15 Vtec02/11/2016FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin
ANR v Bacon dba Bacon Timber Harvest101-6-09 Vtec02/09/2016OrangeHon. Thomas Durkin102-6-09 Vtec, 6-1-11 Vtec
Churchview Estates, LLC NOV9-1-15 Vtec02/01/2016ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Purvis Nonconforming Use45-5-15 Vtec01/27/2016ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
APC Property LLC dba Burlington Bedrooms71-6-15 Vtec01/21/2016ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh116-9-15 Vtec
Legrand and Scata Variance110-8-14 Vtec01/05/2016OrleansHon. Thomas Durkin
expand Decision Year: 2015
NE Materials Group, LLC Act 250143-10-12 Vtec12/23/2015WashingtonHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court Dkt 2016-32 filed 1/20/16
Killington Master Plan Act 250147-10-13 Vtec12/11/2015RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin173-12-13 Vtec, 155-11-14 Vtec
Killington Resort Parking Project155-11-14 Vtec12/11/2015RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin147-10-13 Vtec 173-12-13 Vtec
WhistlePig, LLC A250 JO21-2-13 Vtec11/19/2015AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin
ANR v Colaceci et al65-5-12 Vec11/13/2015LamoilleHon. Thomas Walsh23-5-15 Vtec
Legrand and Scata Variance110-8-14 Vtec11/12/2015OrleansHon. Thomas Durkin
ANR v Bacon, et al101-6-09 Vtec10/28/2015OrangeHon. Thomas Durkin102-6-09 Vtec and 6-1-11 Vtec
Hinesburg Hannaford CU129-9-12 Vtec10/27/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh163-11-12 Vtec, 68-5-14 Vtec,69-5-14 Vtec, 70-5-14 Vtec, 73-5-14 Vtec, 113-8-14 Vtec , 114-8-14 Vtec
Town of Brattleboro v Lawrence68-6-15 Vtec10/19/2015WindhamHon. Thomas Walsh
ANR v McGee94-8-15 Vtec10/09/2015RutlandHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court Appeal Filed 10/23/15 Dkt No. 2015-412
Reap Barn CU57-6-15 Vtec10/07/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Hinesburg Hannaford CU129-9-12 Vtec09/16/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh163-11-12 Vtec, 68-5-14 Vtec,69-5-14 Vtec, 70-5-14 Vtec, 73-5-14 Vtec, 113-8-14 Vtec 114-8-14 Vtec
Rowe et al Act 250 Gravel Pit96-7-12 Vtec09/11/2015RutlandHon. Thomas Walsh102-7-11 Vtec
WhistlePig LLC Act 250 JO21-2-13 Vtec09/02/2015AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin58-5-14 Vtec
38 Tasha Lane Water & Sewer Fees136-9-14 Vtec08/28/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Wagner Guay Permit150-10-14 Vtec08/27/2015Grand IsleHon. Thomas Walsh
Hale Mtn. Fish & Game Permit54-5-13 Vtec08/20/2015BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Camp Abnaki Sign91-7-15 Vtec08/13/2015Grand IsleHon. Thomas Walsh
Moody Subdiv72-5-14 Vtec08/12/2015RutlandHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court Appeal 2015-341 2/11/16 AFFIRMED
Hinesburg Hannaford Water Quality114-8-14 Vtec08/11/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh163-11-12 Vtec, 68-5-14 Vtec,69-5-14 Vtec, 70-5-14 Vtec, 73-5-14 Vtec, 113-8-14 Vtec
Foss NOV (Shared Parking)140-9-14 Vtec07/30/2015LamoilleHon. Thomas Walsh
Roger Rowe et al Act 250 Gravel Pit96-7-12 Vtec07/22/2015RutlandHon. Thomas Walsh
Tilton Variance87-7-14 Vtec07/16/2015EssexHon. Thomas Walsh
934 North Avenue LLC CU121-8-14 Vtec07/15/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
NRB v Stratton Corp106-7-14 Vtec07/13/2015RutlandHon. Thomas Walsh
Vt Turquoise Hospitality LLC131-8-14 Vtec06/24/2015BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Sanfacon NOV48-4-12 Vtec06/23/2015WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh183-12-12 Vtec
Couture SD53-4-14 Vtec06/17/2015AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin
Two Bad Cats LLC169-12-14 Vtec05/29/2015RutlandHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Crt appeal 2015-238 Affirmed
Champlain Farms Site Plan43-4-13 Vtec05/20/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Stakeholders At Danville 05828, Frye v Community National Bank, et al55-5-15 Vtec05/19/2015CaledoniaHon. Thomas Walsh
Warner NOV37-3-14 Vtec05/13/2015OrleansHon. Thomas Walsh
Killington Village Master Plan Act 250147-10-13 Vtec05/13/2015RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin
Budget Inn NOV50-4-13 Vtec05/05/2015WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
NE Materials Grop Act 25035-3-13 Vtec04/30/2015WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh143-10-12 Vtec
Connor Group LLC Major SP CU74-6-13 Vtec04/24/2015FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin
Hale Mtn Fish Game Club Improvement190-11-10 Vtec04/17/2015BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin54-5-13 Vtec
Norris CU65-5-14 Vtec04/14/2015AddisonHon. Thomas Walsh
Dugan Landscape Permit130-8-14 Vtec04/08/2015WindsorHon. Thomas Walsh
Wagner Guay Permit150-10-14 Vtec04/02/2015Grand IsleHon. Thomas Walsh
Hovey Act 250 Permit130-9-13 Vtec03/31/2015EssexHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court 2015-205 Affirmed
Tree Top Dev. Co. Act 25077-6-14 Vtec03/25/2015WindhamHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court Appeal 2015-168 Affirmed 2/11/16
Lakehouse Pub Grille Permit80-6-13 Vtec03/19/2015RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin
Wood NOV and Permit Applications138-8-10 Vtec03/06/2015WindsorHon. Thomas Durkin1-1-11 Vtec
Hinesburg Hannaford Wetland Determination73-5-14 Vtec03/04/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh129-9-12 Vtec, 163-11-12 Vtec, 68-5-14 Vtec, 69-5-14 Vtec, 70-5-14 Vtec 113-8-14 Vtec, 114-8-14 Vtec
Hinesburg Hannaford CU129-9-12 Vtec03/04/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh163-11-12 Vtec, 68-5-14 Vtec,69-5-14 Vtec, 70-5-14 Vtec, 73-5-14 Vtec, 113-8-14 Vtec 114-8-14 Vtec
Dorr Earth Extraction124-9-13 Vtec02/27/2015BenningtonHon. Thomas Walsh
Saxon Hill Sand Extraction42-3-11 Vtec02/25/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas DurkinNKA Allen Brook Dev. Inc. Sand Extraction
Moody SD72-5-14 Vtec02/20/2015RutlandHon. Thomas Walsh
Davis WW WS167-11-14 Vtec02/18/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Orlandi Act 250 Kennel Permit71-5-14 Vtec02/13/2015AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin
St. Johnsbury Academy A25013-1-14 Vtec02/06/2015CaledoniaHon. Thomas Durkin
Hinsdale Trust Boundary Adjustment116-8-14 Vtec02/04/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Hannaford SD Revision68-5-14 Vtec02/04/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh69-5-14 Vtec, 70-5-14 Vtec
Warner NOV37-3-14 Vtec02/02/2015OrangeHon. Thomas Walsh
town of Ludlow v Thomas74-5-14 Vtec01/28/2015WindsorHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court Appeal 2015-082 Dismissed for failure to comply 10/27/15
PCH, Inc. PCG, Inc Building Permit107-7-14 Vtec01/22/2015CaledoniaHon. Thomas Walsh
WhistlePig, LLC Act 25021-2-13 Vtec01/16/2015AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin58-5-14 Vtec, 60-5-14 Vtec
WhistlePig LLC CU60-5-14 Vtec01/09/2015AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin21-2-13 Vtec, 58-5-14 Vtec
Margare Pratt Assisted Living SP111-8-14 Vec01/08/2015OrangeHon. Thomas Durkin112-8-14 Vtec
Champlain Farms SP43-4-13 Vtec01/08/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Farmer Mold & Machine Works, Inc.15-2-14 Vtec01/07/2015RutlandHon. Thomas Walsh
expand Decision Year: 2014
Bradford Oil CAP139-10-13 Vtec12/22/2014WindsorHon. Thomas Walsh307-5-06 Wncv
Kodis Second Story Addition43-3-14 Vtec12/19/2014AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin
Lancaster SD Application1-1-14 Vtec11/24/2014FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin
NRB v Strattom Corp.106-7-14 Vtec11/14/2014RutlandHon. Thomas Walsh
Brisson Gravel Extraction34-3-13 Vtec11/07/2014AddisonHon. Thomas Walsh24-3-13 Vtec SUPREME CRT APPEAL 2014-455 AFFIRMED
Vt Turquoise Hospitality, LLC Discharge Permit131-8-14 Vtec11/06/2014BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Equinox Sq. Assoc. Change of Use64-5-14 Vtec10/31/2014BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Killington Resort Parking Project173-12-13 Vtec10/21/2014RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin143-12-13 Vtec
Dorr et al Earth Extraction124-9-13 Vtec10/10/2014BenningtonHon. Thomas Walsh
B and M Realty Act 250103-8-13 Vtec10/07/2014WindsorHon. Thomas Walsh
Savoy Permit Revision to "As Built"180-12-13 Vtec10/02/2014WindhamHon. Thomas Walsh
Kelley Variance56-4-14 Vtec09/29/2014RutlandHon. Thomas Walsh
Creative Spirit CU99-7-13 Vtec09/26/2014OrangeHon. Thomas Durkin
Hovey Act 250 Permit130-9-13 Vtec09/16/2014AddisonHon. Thomas Walsh
Madden v Town of New Haven49-4-14 Vtec09/12/2014AddisonHon. Thomas Walsh
Town of Colchester v Andres30-3-11 Vtec08/28/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court Appeal Dkt No. 2014-365 Affirned 2/06/2015
Vinagro Waste Transporter76-6-13 Vtec08/22/2014VermontHon. Thomas Walsh
Champlain Parkway68-5-12 Vtec08/21/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court appeal 2014-352 Affirmed 8/21/2015
Wood NOV & Permit Application138-8-10 Vtec08/12/2014WindsorHon. Thomas Durkin1-1-11 Vtec
Union Bank Act 2507-1-12 Vtec08/07/2014LamoilleHon. Thomas Durkin
Killington Resort Parking Project A250173-12-13 Vtec08/05/2014RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin
Moore 3-Lot Subdivision123-9-13 Vtec07/28/2014WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh
DeGraaf Change of Use 62-5-14 Vtec07/24/2014AddisonHon. Thomas Walsh
City of Burlington v Muir117-8-13 Vtec07/23/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
934 North Ave LLC121-8-14 Vtec07/15/2015ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Brothers Building Co. Change of Use119-8-13 Vtec07/10/2014WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Crete and Crete Partnership Construction28-2-14 Vtec07/09/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Bove Demo Const143-10-13 Vtec07/01/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Goodrich Retainin Wall and Access146-10-13 Vtec06/12/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Town of Westford v Mathieu153-9-10 Vtec06/09/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin9-1-11 Vtec, 28-2-12 Vtec
Fielder CU41-3-14 Vtec05/06/2014WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Mt Mansfield UHS Event Board126-9-13 Vtec04/29/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
N.E. Materials Group LLC143-10-12 Vtec04/28/2014WashingtonHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Crt appeal Dkt No. 2014-190
Putney Park and Ride148-11-13 Vtec04/22/2014WindhamHon. Thomas Walsh
Zaremba CU - Jericho101-7-13 Vtec04/21/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Bay Harbor Marina, Inc SP & Variance118-8-13 Vtec04/16/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
WhistlePig, LLC Act 250 JO21-2-13 Vtec04/11/2014AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin
Buckwald Home Occupation CU181-12-13 Vtec04/1/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Champlain Parkway Act 25068-5-12 Vtec03/26/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Jolley Assoc Car Wash Middlebury179-12-13 Vtec03/19/2014AddisonHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court appeal 2014-140 Affirmed
Susan Lee Living Trust Corrective Permit94-7-12 Vtec03/11/2014WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh
Bradford Oil Properety "CAP"139-10-13 Vtec03/06/2014WindsorHon. Thomas Walsh307-5-06 Wncv
Umpire Mtn LLC WW WS171-12-12 Vtec02/27/2014CaledoniaHon. Thomas Walsh
Whiteyville Prop. LLC179-12-11 Vtec02/26/2014ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Zaremba Group Act 250 36-3-13 Vec02/14/2014WindhamHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Crt Appeal 2014-162 6/28/15 AFFIRMED
Lathrop Limited Partnership I122-7-04 Vtec02/11/2014AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin210-9-08 Vtec, 136-8-10 Vtec
Lathrop Limited Partnership I122-7-04 Vtec02/11/2014AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin210-8-08 Vtec, 136-8-10 Vtec
von Trapp CU Permit51-4-13 Vtec02/05/2014WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Godfrey CU OTR67-5-13 Vtec01/23/2014FranklinHon. Thomas Walsh78-6-13 Vtec
Williams Amended CU Permit40-4-13 Vtec01/10/2014WindsorHon. Thomas Durkin
Goddard College CU175-12-11 Vtec01/06/2014WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh173-12-12 Vtec SUPREME CRT APPEAL 2014-049 AFFIRMED
expand Decision Year: 2013
Bissig Subdivision Final Plat87-7-13 Vtec12/23/2013LamoilleHon. Thomas Durkin
Lentz & Laughlin NOV-Variance 158-11-12 Vtec12/10/2013RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin
B M Realty Act 250103-8-13 Vtec11/26/2013WindsorHon. Thomas Walsh
N.E. Materials Grp, LLC Act 250 JO143-10-12 Vtec11/22/2013WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh35-3-13 Vtec
Budget Inn NOV50-4-13 Vtec11/19/2013WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Barefoot & Zweig Act 25046-4-12 Vtec11/13/2013WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Howard Center Renovation Permit12-1-13 Vtec11/12/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court Appeal 2013-463 12/10/13
G and D LLC Permit125-9-13 Vtec11/06/2013LamoilleHon. Thomas Walsh
All Metal Recycling, Inc.171-11-11 Vtec11/01/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court Appeal Dkt No 2013-455 AFFIRMED 8/14/14
Harrison CU Permit155-11-12 Vtec10/31/2013FranklinHon. Thomas Walsh
Smith Building Permit208-12-10 Vtec10/28/2013EssexHon. Thomas Durkin
Williamson Building Permit248-12-09 Vtec10/23/2013FranklinHon. Thomas Walsh184--11-10 Vtec, 185-11-10 Vtec, 14-2-11 Vtec, 55-4-12 Vtec Supreme Court 2013-426 Affirmed
Circus Smirkus Camp CU Permit107-8-13 Vtec10/17/2013OrleansHon. Thomas Durkin
Goddard College CU175-12-11 Vtec09/19/2013WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh173-12-12 Vtec
O'Brien Variance Permit177-12-12 Vtec09/13/2013WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Moody Subdivision45-4-13 Vtec09/11/2013RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin
Atwood Hood PRD Permit Amendment182-12-12 Vtec08/27/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Northeast Materials Group Amended Permit35-3-13 Vtec08/21/2013WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh143-10-12 Vtec
Willowell Foundation CU142-10-12 Vtec08/19/2013OrangeHon. Thomas Walsh
Carrigan CU Application115-8-12 Vtec08/02/2013AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin33-3-13 Vtec, 55-5-13 Vtec Supreme Court Dkt 2013-346 filed 9/9/13
Pelkey Final PLat Major Subdivision172-12-12 Vtec07/26/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin30-3-13 Vtec
Donovan CU83-6-12 Vtec07/24/2013CaledoniaHon. Thomas Walsh
Blasdel and Koch Construction Permit155-10-11 Vtec07/05/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court Appeal 2013-315 11/25/13 Dismissed per w/drawal of appeal
ANR v Sanford64-5-13 Vtec07/02/2013WindsorHon. Thomas Walsh
N.E. Materials Group, LLC35-3-13 Vtec07/02/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh171-11-11 Vtec
McCullough Crushing, Inc. 3-1-10 Vtec06/27/2013WashingtonHon. Thomas WalshDocket No. 279-10-10 Vtec
Town of North Hero v Herrington125-9-12 Vtec06/19/2013Grand IsleHon. Thomas Durkin
Smith Building Permit Garage208-12-10 Vtec06/18/2013EssexHon. Thomas Durkin
NRB v Dorr et al49-4-13 Vtec06/13/2013BenningtonHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Crt Appeal 2013-215 Affitmed 1/9/15
Aisia Minor Hotel Resort Spa124-9-12 Vtec06/04/2013BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Bibby Final Plat 5-Lot SD Waiver189-11-10 Vtec05/30/2013FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin
Town of North Hero v Herrington125-9-12 Vtec05/10/2013Grand IsleHon. Thomas Durkin
Northeast Materials Group, LLC143-10-12 Vtec05/09/2013WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh35-3-13 Vtec
Goddard College CU175-12-11 Vtec04/30/2013WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh
49 Tanglewood Final Plan 76-6-12 Vtec04/22/13ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Howard Cener Renovation Permit12-1-13 Vtec04/12/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Regan Prelin Final SD Plat Approval188-9-09 Vtec04/10/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas DurkinSUPREME COURT APPEAL 2013-281 Affirmed 8/14/14
University Mall, LLC et al v City of So Burlington102-8-12 Vtec04/09/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Barefoot & Zweig Act 250 Appeal46-4-12 Vtec04/05/2013WashingtonHon. Thomas DurkinOriginal Decision; corrected decision issued 4/8/13
Main St. Place, LLC46-3-10 Vtec04/03/2013OrleansHon. Thomas Durkin120-7-10 Vtec, 191-11-10 Vtec, 168-11-11 Vtec, 70-5-11 Vtec
Union Bank Act 250 Application7-1-12 Vtec04/01/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Burlington Airport (Removal of Structures)93-7-12 Vtec03/20/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court Dkt 2013-158 Affirmed 7/25/14
Rockingham School District Permit Revocation20-2-13 Vtec03/16/2013WindhamHon. Thomas Durkin
Williamson Building Permit248-12-09 Vtec03/13/2013FranklinHon. Thomas Walsh184-11-10 Vtec, 185-11-10 Vtec, 14-2-11 Vtec, 55-4-12 Vtec SUPREME CRT APPEAL 2014-481 12/18/14
Donovan CU Permit83-6-12 Vtec03/11/2013CaledoniaHon. Thomas Walsh
Towon of Underhill v Blais13-1-11 Vtec02/27/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
UVM Certificate of Appropriateness90-7-12 Vtec02/26/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Town of Northfield v Drown, et al218-10-08 Vtec02/21/2013WashingtonHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court Appeal Dkt 2013-114 5/17/13 Dismissed failure to comply
Bjerke Zoning Permit Denial72-5-11 Vtec02/14/2013ChittendenHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Crt Appeal Dkt 2013-108 Affirmed 1/24/14
Roystan Ridge Extraction121-7-10 Vtec02/06/2013OrangeHon. Thomas Durkin
Conlon CU Permit2-1-12 Vtec02/05/2013WindsorHon. Thomas Durkin
P & R Associates, LLC74-6-12 Vtec02/01/2013WindhamHon. Thomas Walsh
RACDC Retention Pond62-5-12 Vtec01/29/2013OrangeHon. Thomas Walsh
Blake-Lake Dunmore Road Zoning Permit60-4-10 Vtec01/28/2013AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin153-10-11 Vtec
Southern Vermont Beagle Club49-4-12 Vtec01/18/2013BenningtonHon. Thomas Walsh
Waitsfield Well House CU Application49-4-12 Vtec01/18/1013WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
expand Decision Year: 2012
Roystan Ridge Extraction121-7-10 Vtec12/21/2012OrangeHon. Thomas Durkin
Barefoot & Sweig Act 25046-4-12 Vtec12/21/2012WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Regan Prelim & Final SD Plat188-9-09 Vtec12/18/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
49 Tanglewood Rd.76-6-12 Vtec12/14/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Whiteyville Properties, LLC179-12-11 Vtec12/13/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Freimour & Menard59-4-11 Vtec12/10/2012FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin
Group five Investments LLC CU34-3-11 Vtec12/04/2012AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin
Big Rock Gravel JO116-8-12 Vtec11/28/2012WindhamHon. Thomas Walsh
Town of Berlin v Magoon72-6-12 Vtec11/2/2012WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh
Champlain Parkway Act 25068-5-12 Vtec11/14/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Ferrera & Fenn Gravel Pit159-9-10 Vtec11/13/2012AddisonHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court 2012-456 10/18/13 Affirmed
Union Bank Act 2507-1-12 Vtec11/08/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Cote Site Plan Approval52-4-10 Vtec11/07/2012FranklinHon. Thomas Walsh
Town of Waterford v Bellefeuille153-8-09 Vtec11/01/2012CaledoniaHon. Thomas Walsh
Williamson Building Permit248-12-09 Vtec11/01/2012FranklinHon. Thomas Walsh
ANR v Frye161-10-11 Vtec10/25/2012CaledoniaHon. Thomas Durkin
Bjerke Zoning Permit Denial72-5-11 Vtec10/23/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas WalshSupreme Court appeal filed Dkt 2013-108
Champlain Parkway Act 25068-5-12 Vtec10/12/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Town of Westford v Linda Mathieu153-9-10 Vtec10/10/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Hale Mountain Fish and Game Club190-11-10 Vtec10/04/2012BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin149-8-04 Vtec, 259-12-05 Vtec SUPREME COURT Appeal 2012-412 Affirmed
RACDC Retention Pond62-5-12 Vtec09/27/2012OrangeHon. Thomas Walsh
Twin Pines Housing Trust & Dismas of Vermont CU95-7-11 Vtec09/20/2012WindsorHon. Thomas Walsh96-7-11 Vtec
Fowler NOV159-10-11 Vtec09/19/2012FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin
Caleb Temple dba Kirby Mtn Landscaping CU107-8-11 Vtec09/05/2012CaledoniaHon. Thomas Walsh
Conlon CU Permit2-1-12 Vtec08/30/2012WindsorHon. Thomas Durkin
Conlon CU Permit2-1-12 Vtec08/30/2012WindsorHon. Thomas Durkin
More Accessory Structure161-8-09 Vtec08/10/2012WindsorHon. Merideth WrightSupreme Court Dkt 2012-305 Affirmed 7/19/2023
Smith Building Permit208-12-10 Vtec08/08/2012EssexHon. Thomas Durkin
Fowler NOV159-10-11 Vtec08/08/2012FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin
Vermont Hotel LLC Act 250 Appeal10-1-12 Vtec08/07/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
RACDC Retention Pond62-5-12 Vtec07/31/2012OrangeHon. Thomas Walsh
Town of Fairfax v Beliveau274-11-08 Vtec07/24/2012FranklinHon. Thomas Walsh
Waitasfield Water Supply 39-3-12 Vtec07/20/2012WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin67-5-12 Vtec
Waitsfield Act 250 Water Supply33-2-10 Vtec07/11/2012WashingtonHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court Appeal 2012-280 Dismissed w/prej 8/7/12
Goddard College CU175-12-11 Vtec07/05/2012WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh
Sanfacon NOV48-4-12 Vtec06/29/2012WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh
316 Main St. LLC65-5-11 Vtec06/27/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court appeal 2012-249 12/19/12 Stip of Ptys approved case dismissed
Main St Place LLC46-3-10 Vtec06/19/2012OrleansHon. Thomas Durkin120-7-10 Vtec, 191-11-10 Vtec 168-11-11 Vtec
Main St Place LLC168-11-11 Vtec06/19/2012OrleansHon. Thomas Durkin46-3-10 Vtec, 120-7-10 Vtec, 191-11-10 Vtec
Berger Katz Expansion119-7-10 Vtec06/11/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin141-9-11 Vtec
Freimour and Menard CU59-4-11 Vtec06/06/2012FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin
Schuyler NOV29-2-12 Vtec05/30/2012WindsorHon. Thomas Walsh
Downing Act 250 Application225-11-09 Vtec05/10/2012CaledoniaHon. Merideth Wright
Crandall and Stearns Waiver134-9-11 Vtec05/01/2012OrangeHon. Thomas Walsh
Twin Pines Housing Trust and Dismas of Vermont CU95-7-11 Vtec04/26/2013WindsorHon. Thomas Walsh
Bennington Walmart158-10-11 Vtec04/24/2012BenningtonHon. Thomas Walsh26-2-06 Vtec 49-3-10 Vtec
Hale Mtn Fish and Game Club190-11-10 Vtec04/19/2012BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Bjerke Zoning Appeal Denial72-5-11 Vtec04/17/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Moore Accessory Structure161-8-09 Vtec03/30/2012WindsorHon. Merideth WrightSupreme Court Appeal 2012-305 Affirmed 7/19/13
Foreger Revocable Trust 4-Lot Subdivison157-10-11 Vtec03/29/2012WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh
Brandon Plaza Conditional Use Permit128-8-10 Vtec03/26/2012RutlandHon. Thomas Walsh
Town of Huntington v Goodrich & Harriman27-2-11 Vtec03/21/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
ANR v Henry215-12-10 Vtec03/13/2012Grand IsleHon. Thomas Durkin
Chaves Londonderry Gravel Pit, LLC and David Chaves Act 25060-4-11 Vtec03/09/2012WindhamHon. Thomas Durkin267-11-08 Vtec
Hartland Group Real Estate94-7-11 Vtec03/01/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Lake Champlain Bluegrass Festival JO204-11-10 Vtec02/23/2012Grand IsleHon. Thomas Durkin
ANR v Second City Property, LLC & Second City, LLC100-7-11 Vtec02/16/2012RutlandHon. Thomas Walsh
Moran Site Plan and Major Impact Development4-1-12 Vtec02/15/2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh154-10-11 Vtec
Hurricane Auto CU Application92-7-11 Vtec02/13/2012WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh
Saman ROW Approval176-10-10 Vtec02/06/2012WashingtonHon. Thomas Walsh
Frantz Wastewater & Water Supply Permit173-10-10 Vtec01/19/ 2012ChittendenHon. Thomas Walsh
Lake Champlain Bluegrass Festival JO204-11-10 Vtec01/03/2012Grand IsleHon. Thomas Durkin
expand Decision Year: 2011
Chaves Londonderry Gravel Pit, LLC & David Chaves60-4-11 Vtec12/22/2011WindhamHon. Thomas Durkin
Fontaine Act 250 Application12-1-10 Vtec12/20/2011ChittendenHon. Merideth Wright143-9-10 Vtec
Noyes CU Permit98-7-11 Vtec12/12/11WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Town of Georgia v King105-6-10 Vtec11/30/2011FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin
Ferry and Pomeroy Demo-Const. Permit197-10-09 Vtec11/22/2011ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Waitsfield Source Permit128-8-11 Vtec11/16/2011WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Harvey and West 65 Unit Campground Act 250 Application110-7-10 Vtec11/09/2011LamoilleHon. Merideth WrightSupreme Court Appeal Dkt 2011-428 1/3/12 AA's notice of appeal was untimely filed, we therefore lack juridcition. Dismissed.
Chaves Londonderry Gravel Pit60-4-11 Vtec11/07/2011WindhamHon. Thomas Durkin
Frostbite Mine12-1-11 Vtec11/03/2011WindsorHon. Thomas Durkin
Hartland Group Real Estate94-7-11 Vtec11/01/2011ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Lowre Variance19-2-11 Vtec10/24/2011CaledoniaHon. Thomas Durkin
Lawrence Site Plan Approval166-10-10 Vtec10/17/2011WindhamHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court Appeal Filed Dkt 2011-405 12/8/11 Dismissed for Lack of Jurisdiction (untimely)
ANR v Deering and Andrews170-10-10 Vtec10/12/2011AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin
Ferrera and Fenn Gravel Pit Application159-9-10 Vtec09/29/2011AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin
Wells Building Application44-3-11 Vtec09/26/2011WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Transtar LLC46-3-11 Vtec09/15/2011BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Stoe Highlands Lot Merger and Subdivision Application35-3-11 Vtec09/09/2011LamoilleHon. Thomas Durkin
Beliveau Notice of Violation193-8-08 Vtec09/02/2011FranklinHon. Merideth Wright274-11-08 Vtec Supreme Court appeal filed 4/13/12 Dkt Nos. 2012-135 - 2012-136
Saman ROW Approval176-10-10 Vtec09/02/2011WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Fenoff Variance Amendment32-2-10 Vtec08/30/2011OrleansHon. Merideth Wright196-9-08 Vtec
Hale Mountain Fish & Game Club Improvement Application190-11-10 Vtec08/23/2011BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Hale Mountain Fish & Game Club, Inc. Improvement Application190-11-10 Vtec08/23/2011BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Fennessey's 20 West Main Street LLC14-1-10 Vtec08/19/2011WindhamHon. Merideth Wright154-9-10 Vtec
Brandan Plaza CU Permit128-8-10 Vtec08/05/2011RutlandHon. Merideth Wright
Losier Variance Application79-4-08 Vtec08/02/2011EssexHon. Thomas DurkinPost Judgment Decision; Previously appealed to Supreme Court Dkt 2010-309 1/27/11 Affirmed
Losier Variance Application79-4-08 Vtec08/02/2011EssexHon. Thomas DurkinPost Judgment Decision; previously appealed to Supreme Court Dkt No. 2010-309 Affirmed 1/27/11
Lawrence Site Plan Approval166-10-10 Vtec07/27/2011WindhamHon. Thomas Durkin
Lawrence Site Plan Approval166-10-10 Vtec07/27/2011WindhamHon. Thomas Durkin
Cummings Subdivision156-9-10 Vtec07/13/2011FranklinHon. Merideth Wright
Wood NOV and Permit Applications138-8-10 Vtec07/08/2011WindsorHon. Thomas Durkin1-1-11 Vtec
Granville Mfg Co., Inc. Act 250 2-1-11 Vtec07/01/2011AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin
Verizon Wireless Westford Site CU & SP49-4-11 Vtec06/23/2011ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Barry (Clyde's Place, LLC) NOV142-7-07 Vtec05/23/2011AddisonHon. Merideth Wright
Wood NOV & Permit Application138-8-10 Vtec05/20/2011WindsorHon. Thomas Durkin1-1-11 Vtec
Omya Solid Waste Facililty Final Certification96-6-10 Vtec05/16/2011RutlandHon. Merideth Wright
Nancy Lewis Revocable Trust Variance110-6-08 Vtec04/29/2011ChittendenHon. Merideth Wright
Richard Notice of Violation151-9-10 Vtec04/29/2011ChittendenHon. Merideth Wright
Verizon Wireless Barton Act 250 Permit6-1-10 Vtec04/21/2011OrleansHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Crt Appeal Docket No. 2011-204 Affirmed 5/1/2012
Saman ROW and Subdivision176-10-10 Vtec04/21/2011WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Schwarzkopf 4-Lot Subdivision94-6-10 Vtec04/06/2011RutlandHon. Thomas DurkinThis is an Amended Judgment Order; original issued 3/9/2011
Kelsey Notice of Violation123-7-10 Vtec03/18/2011Grand IsleHon. Merideth Wright
Musty Zoning Permit174-10-10 Vtec03/09/2011ChittendenHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court Appeal Dkt 2011-290 7/12/11
Schwarzkopf 4-Lot Subdivision94-6-10 Vtec03/09/2011RutlandHon. Thomas DurkinAmended Judgment Order issued 4/6/2011
Omya Solid Waste Facility Interim Certification273-11-08 Vtec02/28/2011RutlandHon. Merideth Wright96-6-10 Vtec
Musty Permit174-10-10 Vtec02/24/2011ChittendenHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court Appeal Dkt No. 2011-290 7/12/11
Moore Accessory Structure Permit161-8-09 Vtec02/17/2011WindsorHon. Merideth Wright
Town of Charlotte Recreational Trail98-5-08 Vtec02/14/2011ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin58-4-10 Vtec
Berger & Katz Application119-7-10 Vtec02/04/2011ChittendenHon. Merideth Wright
Toor and Toor Living Trust NOV 18-1-10 Vtec01/31/2011Grand IsleHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court Appeal Dkt No. 2011-085 3/3/11
Musto Cosntruction Permit132-7-09 Vtec01/27/2011RutlandHon. Merideth Wright
Ridgewood Est. HOA & Indian Creek HOA Association57-4-10 Vtec01/26/2011ChittendenHon. Merideth Wright
Champlain Marina Dock Expansion28-2-09 Vtec01/10/2011ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Sheffield Wind Project252-10-08 Vtec01/06/2011CaledoniaHon. Merideth WrightSupreme Court appeal 2011-046 10/25/11 Pursuant to AA notice of w/drawal, AE M Dismiss denied for mootness
expand Decision Year: 2010
Fenoff Variance Amendment32-2-10 Vtec12/27/2010OrleansHon. Merideth Wright196-9-08 Vtec
Gaujac Final Site Plan PUD Review145-9-10 Vtec12/14/2010ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Martin and Martin Variance Application215-11-09 Vtec12/03/2010BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Bowen Conditional Use Application93-6-10 Vtec11/29/2010FranklinHon. Merideth WrightSupreme Crt Appeal 2011-112 Affirmed 7/7/2011
Hawk's Nest South, LLP Conditional Use/PUD Applications84-5-10 Vtec11/29/2010FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin
Saladino Site Plan Application223-11-090 Vtec11/22/2010OrangeHon. Thomas Durkin224-11-09 Vtec
Merchant & Anderson Site Plan Application205-10-09 Vtec11/18/2010WindhamHon. Thomas Durkin
Hawk's Nest South, LLP Condition Use PUD84-5-10 Vtec11/17/2010FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin
Waitsfield Public Water System Act 250 Permit33-2-10 Vtec11/03/2010WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Verizon Wireless Barton Act 250 Permit6-1-09 Vtec10/29/2010OrleansHon. Thomas Durkin
Rinkers, Inc. d/b/a Rinkers Communication & Shepard302-12-08 Vtec10/20/2010CaledoniaHon. Merideth WrightSupreme Court Appeal 2010-446 7/13/2011 Affirmed
Big Rock Gravel, LLC Act 250 JO174-8-09 Vtec10/19/2010WindhamHon. Merideth Wright
ANR v The Copper Mine Corp.210-10-09 Vtec10/1/2010WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Highlands Development Co., LLC & JAM Golf, LLC Master Plan Application194-10-03 Vtec09/21/2010ChittendenHon. Merideth Wright
Waitsfield Public Water System Act 250 Permit33-2-10 Vtec09/15/2010WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Morrill House, LLC & Smith Variance27-2-10 Vtec09/03/2010AddisonHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court Appeal 2010-376 Affirmed 9/3011
Rivers Development, LLC Conditional Use Appeal7-1-05 Vtec08/17/2010WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin68-3-07 Vtec
Grist Mill Horse Barn Redevelopment Plan 2nd Appeal89-5-09 Vtec08/05/2010AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin
Sullivan & Schiavone v Lakeview Inn Enterprises, LLC et al125-7-09 Vtec08/02/2010OrleansHon. Thomas Durkin
Town of Newbury v Celeste50-3-10 Vtec07/28/2010OrangeHon. Merideth Wright
Agri-Mark Indirect Discharge Permit Amendment63-4-10 Vtec07/20/2010WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Woodstock Community Trust & Housing Vt. PUD203-10-09 Vtec07/13/2010WindsorHon. Merideth Wright
Lidstone Variance & Waiver65-4-10 Vtec07/13/2010RutlandHon. Merideth Wright
Tyler Self-Storage Units Permit189-9-09 Vtec07/09/2010BenningtonHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Crt Appeal Filed Dkt No. 2010-307 6/23/11 Reversed
Nordlund v Van Nostrand et al42-3-10 Vtec07/07/2010AddisonHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Crt Appeal Filed 08/02/10 Dkt 2010-283
Pion Sand & Gravel Pit245-12-09 Vtec07/02/2010OrleansHon. Thomas Durkin
Feeley Construction Permits4-1-10 Vtec06/16/2010ChittendenHon. Merideth Wright5-1-10 Vtec Supreme Court appeal filed 8/2/11 Dkt No. 201-273
Champlain Marina Dock Expansion28-2-09 Vtec06/16/2010ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Saladino CU Application223-11-09 Vtec06/01/2010OrangeHon. Thomas Durkin224-11-09 Vtec
Champlain Marina Dock Expansion28-2-09 Vtec05/19/2010ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Baldwin Property Act 250 JO255-12-09 Vtec05/06/2010ChittendenHon. Merideth Wright
JLD Prop St. Albans Wal Mart 116-6-08 Vtec05/03/2010FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin92-5-07 Vtec, 242-10-06 Vtec, 80-4-08 Vtec Original decision issued 1/20/2010 Supreme Court Dkt 2010-097 filed 4/5/10
Myers 2-Lot Subdivision Final Plat121-6-09 Vtec04/28/2010WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
Rodriques Variance Application212-9-08 Vtec04/27/2010EssexHon. Thomas Durkin
Geddes PUD231-11-09 Vtec04/20/2010FranklinHon. Merideth Wright
ANR v Bacon d/b/a Bacon Timber Harvesting102-6-09 Vtec04/19/2010LamoilleHon. Thomas Durkin
Grist Mill Horse Barn Redevelopment Plan205-9-08 Vtec04/13/2010AddisonHon. Thomas Durkin
SP Land Co., et al Act 250 Land Use257-11-08 Vtec04/12/2010RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin
Tanquay Storage Unit Permit149-7-09 Vtec04/07/2010FranklinHon. Merideth Wright
Bouffard Family PRD Preliminary Plat43-3-09 Vtec04/05/2010ChittendenHon. Thomas Durkin
Times & Seasons LLC Act 250 Reconsideration45-3-09 Vtec03/29/2010WindsorHon. Thomas DurkinSupreme Court Appeal 2010-154 7/8/11 Affirmed
Benning Accessory Use Permit184-9-09 Vtec03/25/2010AddisonHon. Merideth Wright
Sprague Farms, LLC CU & SP107-6-08 Vtec03/10/2010OrangeHon. Merideth Wright12/6/10 JO issued with this decision being partially vacated
Krag Special Zoning Permit for Culvert51-4-09 Vtec03/05/2010ChittendenHon. Merideth Wright
O'Neil Sand & Gravel Act 250 Amendment Application48-2-07 Vtec02/23/2010WindsorHon. Merideth Wright226-9-06 Vtec
Gerlach Area Parking Permit31-2-09 Vtec02/18/2010WashingtonHon. Thomas Durkin
DeRoy Variance Applications14-1-09 Vtec02/16/2010RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin
Main Street Place, LLC Demolition Permit163-8-09 Vtec02/12/2010OrleansHon. Thomas Durkin
Hale Mountain Fish & Game Club149-8-04 Vtec02/03/2010BenningtonHon. Thomas Durkin259-12-05 Vtec Supreme Crt Appeal Filed 2010-083 Dismissed 5/14/10 W/drawn by AA
Verizon Wireless Act 250 Permit Barton6-1-09 Vtec02/02/2010OrleansHon. Thomas Durkin
JLD Property St. Albans Wal Mart116-6-08 Vtec01/20/2010FranklinHon. Thomas Durkin129-5-06 Vtec, 242-10-06 Vtec, 92-5-07 Vtec, 80-4-08 Vtec 5/3/2010 Decisions on Motions to Amend Issued (2) Supreme Crt Dkt 2010-097 filed 4/5/10
Town of Fairfax v Beliveau274-11-08 Vtec01/13/2010ChittendenHon. Merideth Wright193-8-08 Vtec Supreme Court 2010-064 & 065; 7/16/10 Reversed & Remanded
Godnick Family Trust Permit & Variance Application52-4-09 Vtec01/06/2010RutlandHon. Thomas Durkin
expand Decision Year: